Based on your story, my opinion is that he definitely owes you. I would rather have a refund than another animal from this source.
In the interest of avoiding a long convoluted denial in which the seller may try and refute your story by implying that you changed some of the messages posted, and that you did indeed kill the animals (attempting to confuse the issue)I would post the messages in their entirety (pictures of the texts rather than a word document).
Just to keep the chain of information clear and indisputable.
|