I am surprised that I am the first person asking this after 225 plus posts.
What were the TOS that were discussed / in place on this transaction? That will dictate what the remedy due is.
The blackmail issue aside, if there were no firm TOS in place or discussed then the remedy is usually up to the seller. It sounds like a suitable replacement animal is still available. Given the rancor and questionable acts perpetrated by the seller and his cronies, I think the best solution is a hand delivery to the next local show. A refund would be easier but the seller is not obligated to choose that course.
Just my take...carry on with the public flogging!
