I will happily give my honest opinion, and try not to be too harsh.
- Not digging the green, it's too bright. If you want the green, I would shoot for the dark green seen in the Quick Reply bar here on Fauna.
- The counter looks pretty unprofessional (specifically with the advertisment beneath) and doesn't go match the rest of your design. I use
http://www.statcounter.com for my counters.
- The BOI cert looks out of place and really doesn't need to be on every page
- The typography (text) on the Terms & Help pages is very distracting. It seems simply thrown onto the page and doesn't have any unity or order (see
www.triplemoonsexotic.com/terms.html for a good example of typography for your terms page)
- The yellow on the Links page made me wince, I would stick with one color throughout your pages
I think that about covers out. Love the font by the way (I'm a font junky)!