The world’s biggest reptile fair is also a hub for traffickers - FaunaClassifieds
FaunaClassifieds  
 Sponsors »  Breeders | Dealers |  Importers/Exporters | Caging | Feed | Supplies | Services | Events 
  Inside FaunaClassifieds » Product Reviews |  Classifieds!   | Photo Gallery   | Banner Advertising 
 
  Want to help keep this site alive? Click here.

Go Back   FaunaClassifieds > Reptile & Amphibian - General Discussion Forums > Herps In The News

Notices

Herps In The News Local or national articles where reptiles or amphibians have made it into the news media. Please cite sources.

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 06-06-2019, 03:07 PM   #1
JColt
The world’s biggest reptile fair is also a hub for traffickers

HAMM, Germany — Two hours before the fair opens on a cold day in March, hundreds of people are already queuing in the cold. “The best merchandise is sold in the morning,” a shivering woman explains outside. She’s looking to expand her collection of exotic pet centipedes, and the Terraristika reptile fair in the German city of Hamm is the perfect place to do so. “You’ll find everything you wouldn’t find anywhere else,” she says.

Styrofoam boxes loaded on dollies are pushed past the queue and inside the steamy warehouse, where some of the world’s most prolific wildlife breeders and traders are getting ready to sell tens of thousands of not just reptiles like snakes and lizards but also spiders, centipedes, insects and frogs.

The fair itself is simply referred to as “Hamm,” after the nondescript town in the middle of Germany’s rust belt where it’s held four times a year. Touting itself as the largest reptile trade show in the world, it’s a bazaar brimming with more than 550 sellers who set up shop, reptile-enthusiasts and specialized transport companies that pick the animals up and drive them back to their clients in countries like the U.K. Some have come from as far as South Korea and the U.S., pushing past Indian giant tiger centipedes (Scolopendra hardwickei), which cost $550 a piece, and common pythons on offer as a “buy 2 get 3” deal.

For buyers, sellers and middlemen, Hamm is the pinnacle of a growing international trade worth millions of dollars annually, and a meeting point for aficionados seeking the rarest and best “merchandise,” as the animals are referred to, from Chinese crocodile lizards (Shinisaurus crocodilurus) to manabi bird-eater tarantulas (Pamphobeteus sp. mascara) and beetles belonging to the scarab family (Scarabaeidae).

For conservationists, however, Hamm is something else: the biggest real-life marketplace for reptile traffickers who have learned to exploit the European Union’s weak laws and lack of enforcement to sell high-value, endangered, and protected species.

“The things that are being sold there, you can’t even imagine,” says biologist Sandra Altherr, who co-founded the German conservation group Pro Wildlife. “There are lots of reptiles that are protected, and they are being sold freely at Hamm.”


Reptiles change hands at the “Hamm” reptile fair. Image by anonymous.
Snakes in the parking lot
Hours before the fair officially opens, the parking lot of the nearby Cafe del Sol is bustling. Because not every seller pays for a stall, merchandise is also traded online — often on Facebook groups, despite Facebook’s ban on trading live animals — and exchanged in the parking lot.

Phones keep buzzing as buyers and sellers seek out each other. “Where are you? I’m wearing a red backpack,” a middle-aged man with a southern German accent says. “Look for someone Chinese, that’s me,” another buyer describes himself.

Poisonous snakes, scorpions and other animals are pulled out of their Styrofoam boxes, and payments of hundreds, sometimes thousands of euros are made in cash or via PayPal.

Each transaction comes with a quickly filled-in and pre-typed “proof of origin” form, in which the seller simply attests that he sold a specific, captive-bred animal to the new buyer. No matter the international conservation status of the species, captive-bred individuals can generally be sold legally in Germany unless local laws specifically state otherwise. In many cases, a “proof of origin” letter is all one needs to show that the animal wasn’t poached from the wild — even though it may not be true.

Altherr says that Hamm marks a “proliferation of the illegal trade” as a lack of oversight and inspections, and a general disregard for low-priority crimes such as the trafficking of reptiles, allows traders to sell any species they’d like. These include animals that are threatened with extinction and could have been poached from the wild in countries like Madagascar or Sri Lanka, and trafficked to Germany.

Representative of local police and customs authorities who were not allowed to speak to the media confirmed to Mongabay that they were not going to inspect the fair in March. In 2015, however, a German customs unit followed a tipoff that led them to a hotel room in Hamm where more than 130 reptiles and amphibians, many of them protected and threatened species, were being sold on the sidelines.

The vast majority of reptiles at the fair can legally be sold, but, as one trader at Hamm put it: “If you’re looking for a special animal, I won’t say it’s not possible.”


The Hamm reptile fair touts itself as the largest reptile trade show in the world. Image by anonymous.
Legal loopholes
International trade in certain animal and plant species is subject to restrictions under CITES, the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora, which aims to ensure that threatened species aren’t pushed toward extinction by commercial trade. However, CITES only protects 8 percent of the world’s 10,700 known reptile species from the commercial trade.

Many more reptile species are protected under national laws, though. Since CITES generally lists species once their numbers are dwindling and trafficking has become rampant, the governments of countries like Australia, New Zealand, South Africa, Sri Lanka, Brazil and Cuba have banned trading endemic wildlife in the hope of never seeing their numbers dwindle in the first place.

It’s a pre-emptive measure, but one with gaping loopholes, says Jordi Janssen, a program officer with the Canada-based NGO Monitor Conservation Research Society, who specializes in the reptile trade. While nationally protected reptiles shouldn’t make it out of the country protecting them, bans no longer apply once they cross the borders.

“This grey area is really the biggest problem at the moment,” Janssen says. Sri Lanka, he says, is a good example.

Out of the tropical island state’s 219 reptile species, many of which are endemic, all but four snakes are protected from being collected in the wild or traded. Yet trafficking in these species appears to be on the rise, Janssen and his colleague, Sri Lankan biologist Anslem de Silva, found in a recent study published in April this year.

The pair monitored online trade websites and a number of Facebook groups between 2016 and 2018 and found several hundred Sri Lankan reptiles for sale across Europe, with Germany being identified as the main hub. Most were advertised as captive-bred, but some were openly advertised as having been poached from the wild.

Protected at home, sold at Hamm
Species that fall under that category — protected by national law but not beyond the border — are a common sight at Hamm. Take, for example, Tiliqua rugosa. Known as the bobtail, this blue-tongued skink is relatively common in its native Australia, where it’s protected from trade under the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act. This has made it a rare and highly coveted pet reptile outside Australia, with individuals fetching prices of more than $4,000. At Hamm, it’s one of the most expensive merchandises on offer.

“At the moment, they are really into curly endives,” a German breeder selling the reptiles, kept in small, glass terrariums, explains to an interested buyer from South Korea. All of them were bred in captivity, he says, given the strict regulations in Australia. Mongabay could not confirm his claims.

Both Altherr and Janssen say that no German or EU law stops the breeder from selling the species, even though at one point a couple of bobtails were trafficked out of Australia to begin captive breeding.


Tiliqua rugosa, protected in Australia, is a coveted pet at reptile fairs. Image by Donald Hobern via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 2.0)
Just how tightly wound the legal and illegal trade are is exemplified by some of the sellers’ criminal records, with arrests for smuggling in countries like Costa Rica, New Zealand and Madagascar, according to news reports. Despite their records, fair organizer Frank Izaber continues to provide them with a trade platform. Izaber declined to comment for this story.

Journalists aren’t welcome at the fair, and photography is strictly banned. Security guards patrol the venue to remind everyone with a phone that they’ll be “escorted outside” if they don’t comply. Altherr says her advocacy got her banned from the fair.

To stymie the trade in Europe, conservationists have proposed a law modeled after the U.S. Lacey Act, which bans the trade in any species that was taken, transported or sold in violation not just of U.S. law, but the law of any foreign country of origin.

Such a regulation would also be needed in Europe, which experts say has become a popular hub and destination for trafficked wildlife, not just due to Hamm.

In 2015 alone, more than 2,000 reptiles were seized at the EU’s borders, which is believed to be less than 10 percent of the actual trade. In 2018, Spanish authorities dismantled an international reptile trafficking ring and confiscated more than 600 reptiles collected from all over the world. How many had already been trafficked and sold is unclear.

What is certain, however, is that reptile trafficking is highly lucrative. Some species can be bought for a few dozen dollars in their country of origin, are easily smuggled past airport and border authorities in check-in luggage or shipments, and can be sold in countries like Germany for thousands of euros per individual. Izaber told a local paper in 2014 that some traders make 200,000 euros ($223,000) or more at the fair.

It’s so lucrative, in fact, that it pays off to fly in all the way from Asia, said the three South Koreans who had been bargaining for the Australian bobtail. They bought it for a little over 4,000 euros ($4,460). Toward the end of the fair, the trio had grabbed a table at the bustling Cafe del Sol. Together, they had spent more than 50,000 euros ($55,800) — a good exploit that will make them several times the buying price at home. Trading reptiles, they say, is their main job, and so they’ll be back for the next fair on June 1 this year.

“Hamm,” one of them says, pausing as he chews on a steak, “It’s just the best.”

https://news.mongabay.com/2019/05/th...r-traffickers/
 
Old 06-08-2019, 06:14 PM   #2
alex bleas
When you captive breed rare reptile and sale them it’s perfectly fine. We don’t need the government coming in and killing are babies that we worked hard to produce. What is the purpose of post? To show lots or people work hard at breeding reptiles and get rewarded.
 
Old 06-08-2019, 06:17 PM   #3
alex bleas
Farmers like to hit rare reptile in the head with machete’s while they expand their farms go bother them.
 
Old 06-08-2019, 09:57 PM   #4
sschind
Quote:
Originally Posted by alex bleas View Post
When you captive breed rare reptile and sale them it’s perfectly fine. We don’t need the government coming in and killing are babies that we worked hard to produce. What is the purpose of post? To show lots or people work hard at breeding reptiles and get rewarded.
I think part of the purpose of the post is to point out that not all the rare reptiles that are claimed to be captive bred are in fact captive bred and some people are rewarded for lying about it.
 
Old 06-09-2019, 10:37 AM   #5
JColt
Quote:
Originally Posted by alex bleas View Post
What is the purpose of post?
Well for one it is news about herps. Every thing in life has a good and bad side. Just discussing good doesn't bring positive change. I think a large portion of ethical breeders and keepers abhor the dark side of herp community.

If we want it cleaned we need to do it or the government will and probably not to our liking.
 
Old 06-09-2019, 01:24 PM   #6
James L
The article does have a negative biased tone towards herp keeping in my opinion. If I'm not mistaken, Tiliqua rugosa has been kept and bred in Germany for many years.
 
Old 06-10-2019, 01:10 PM   #7
JimM
It certainly does have that negative tone that most article covering herp breeding has. The fact that the article didn't mention that shingle backed skinks has been bred in Germany by dedicated keepers gives it that typical, rotten outlook towards reptile breeders.

That's what journalists are trained and encouraged to do .... push bad news, put a negative spin on everything. Why spoil a good story with the facts ?
 
Old 06-10-2019, 10:33 PM   #8
Socratic Monologue
Quote:
Originally Posted by James L View Post
The article does have a negative biased tone towards herp keeping in my opinion. If I'm not mistaken, Tiliqua rugosa has been kept and bred in Germany for many years.
Quote:
Originally Posted by JimM View Post
It certainly does have that negative tone that most article covering herp breeding has. The fact that the article didn't mention that shingle backed skinks has been bred in Germany by dedicated keepers gives it that typical, rotten outlook towards reptile breeders.

That's what journalists are trained and encouraged to do .... push bad news, put a negative spin on everything. Why spoil a good story with the facts ?
Both good points; the article should have been more interested in relaying the facts, rather than supporting the hypothesis given in the title of the piece.

It is worth mentioning that all Tiliqua rugosa in captivity (and all, or nearly all, Australian animals, for that matter) are either themselves smuggled or are the descendants of smuggled animals -- another point that may have been worth space in the article.

In fact, some were smuggled last week:

https://newsroom.abf.gov.au/releases...zard-smuggling

I think this is important enough that it bears repeating:
Quote:
Originally Posted by JColt View Post
If we want it cleaned we need to do it or the government will and probably not to our liking.
 
Old 06-11-2019, 03:37 PM   #9
JimM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Socratic Monologue View Post
It is worth mentioning that all Tiliqua rugosa in captivity (and all, or nearly all, Australian animals, for that matter) are either themselves smuggled or are the descendants of smuggled animals -- another point that may have been worth space in the article.

I think this is important enough that it bears repeating:
Of course they were all smuggled at some point - no Australian species were ever imported legally I dont think , especially not to the private sector. And if they weren't snuck into the country many years ago and the right keepers / breeders hadn't gotten them, there would be no dragons, dwarf monitors, diamonds, carpets, skinks, etc. in the private sector right now.

I'm not encouraging smuggling animals just pointing out the facts of how it all turned out. Seems to me whatever was smuggled in 30 - 40 years ago didn't have an impact on the wild population and if anything took pressure off the wild populations as these desireable species are readily available as captive bred. If breeders tried to do it with the legal permits and paper work, it would never , ever happened.

It got bad enough ( or good enough depending what side you're on ) that Fish and Game has to make up new laws every year to now bust you for breeding in your own home since it's getting harder and harder to get someone coming out of the woods with a snake in a bag.

I guess though if some felt strongly enough about having animals that decended from illegal / smuggled animals 30 years ago they could always turn their baby diamond pythons over to Fish and Game when they hatch instead of listing them in the classifieds
 
Old 06-11-2019, 03:50 PM   #10
Socratic Monologue
Quote:
Originally Posted by JimM View Post
Seems to me whatever was smuggled in 30 - 40 years ago didn't have an impact on the wild population and if anything took pressure off the wild populations as these desireable species are readily available as captive bred. If breeders tried to do it with the legal permits and paper work, it would never , ever happened.
I understand the sentiment, but there are cases that show these statements cannot be generalized. One: there are locales of dart frogs that were smuggled to extirpation, so the 'impact on wild populations' issue is sometimes a problem. Two: there are (claimed to be...) breeders of T. rugosa, but still they get smuggled. It is cheaper/easier/quicker/more exciting to steal many of these animals than it is to raise them.

The main reason Australian herps haven't suffered from collection pressures as much as, say, many species geographically located between -- and including -- the US and Brazil is because Australia's wildlife laws are tough and well-enforced.

Also, Australia should have the final say on what happens to wildlife within its borders, no matter if stealing some if it wouldn't cause Australia any harm, or 'how it turns out'. If a person/people/nation wants to be respected, they must also respect others. Unfortunately, this is a hard concept for many to grasp.

Quote:
Originally Posted by JimM View Post
I guess though if some felt strongly enough about having animals that decended from illegal / smuggled animals 30 years ago they could always turn their baby diamond pythons over to Fish and Game when they hatch instead of listing them in the classifieds
That's just silly, and you know it is. You wanted facts, Jim, and I pointed out the relevant one that much of our hobby is founded on smuggling. A person can admit that in the open, and feel regret that things are so, without making ridiculous claims to deflect those feelings of regret.
 

Join now to reply to this thread or open new ones for your questions & comments! FaunaClassifieds.com is the largest online community about Reptile & Amphibians, Snakes, Lizards and number one classifieds service with thousands of ads to look for. Registration is open to everyone and FREE. Click Here to Register!

 
Reply

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
New(ish) to the reptile world. MedicRoby The Welcome Room & New Member Intros 1 11-08-2013 10:38 PM
Reptile News: Thailand's biggest poacher arrested jasonw Herps In The News 0 02-18-2011 10:51 AM
Puyallup Wa. Oct 16 & 17 reptile show Fair grounds Rock Star Reptile Shows & Events 0 09-28-2010 02:36 PM
Thick-shelled turtle species lived with world's biggest snake, reveals fossil found i RSS_news Herps In The News 0 04-06-2010 02:20 PM
[For Sale] The reptile world dwarfboakeeper All Other Herp Related Material 0 03-12-2010 09:32 PM


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 03:36 AM.




Ebates Coupons and Cash Back


TESTING!
Fauna Top Sites


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.3
Copyright ©2000 - 2019, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Page generated in 0.06020808 seconds with 10 queries
Content copyrighted ©2002-2018, FaunaClassifieds, LLC