Rescued American Toad Help?

Hello, everyone! Tonight, my friend and I went walking around his property, and when we looked into a partially-covered well in his front yard, we found two American toads (a male and female) trapped and treading water. We fished them out with a net and put them in a bucket before agreeing to bring them in and try to help them out. The female is extremely malnourished but feisty, and the male is not as malnourished but much more timid. They’re both very weak and small overall.

We placed the toads into a plastic bin that is about 36”x18”x18”, and we added mealworms and beetles dusted with multivitamin powder, bark for hiding under, a shallow water dish with conditioned water, and Eco Earth. His sister has some geckos, so we were lucky enough to have extra materials. We drilled holes into into the sides of the bin, and it has a locking lid. My friend’s house is kept at around 70°F.

Is there anyone more experienced with keeping toads that could help us out with some care tips for these little guys? We’re trying not to touch them too much for a little while because they were handled a good bit tonight and have generally been traumatized by what they’ve been through. Any suggestions would be appreciated.

1) Keep them only as long as necessary. It is in their best interest to release them back outdoors. I'm sorry I have no experience with keeping toads, but it is my understanding they do not do well in captivity, especially if WC.

2) Cover that freaking well!!

Yeah, just release them around dusk. They can take care of themselves. We have lots of toads around here, and just leave them to their own devices. We have to use flashlights at night so we can avoid stepping on them in the pathways.

This one took up residence underneath our pool pump.