Hello everyone,
I apologize for taking so long to make this post. I simply don't have a lot of spare time, and I have some other limitations that prevented me. I agree with Lucille it is important that I respond to the questions raised here, and I intend to do so at length. Let me also apologize for the length of this post. There have been so many attacks, as well as legitimate questions, that it has taken me quite some time to compile them, and assemble my responses and their accompanying evidence. As an adult, I have never been subjected to this sort of attack, and to be honest, I wasn't really sure the appropriate way to begin to respond to it, and I found that it takes a lot of time and effort to address every slight, implication and lie when they are piled on so heavily, and across so many different websites.
l also find it incredibly deflating to be subjected to this many insults when I have always tried to do my best and help our community and the animals we love. I would be lying if I said it didn't bring me down a bit to read through this thread. As I have said before, I am by no means perfect, and I have made some blunders; big ones, and I freely admit it. All I can do, all anyone can do, is to attempt to make them right and move forward. I am trying to do so, despite people like Gregg who are standing in the way.
Also, I'm sure that this post will not be the end of this for Gregg. I'm sure he will do his research and find any little moment he can exploit to show I'm not perfect, and that I have screwed up. I'll save him the trouble. I'm not perfect. I have screwed up. I am doing my best. I have said the wrong thing, I have misled people, and I have withheld information when I shouldn't have. I am sure that if any one of us was scrutinized and had our deeds and misdeeds spread out all over the internet, we could be made to look like bad people. I'm not unique. I am trying to be my best. I'm trying to do what is right, and that is all I can offer.
While I don't think that this thread will have any significant effect on my future business, I think it is important that when a person makes a specious and malevolent statement, or campaign in this case, that it is dealt with clearly and quickly for the benefit of all involved.
I have been keeping snakes since I was 16, and I have been working with hogs for about 16 years. I produce and sell extremely high quality western hognosed snakes, and I take the utmost care and time with each snake. I make sure that they are feeding well, large and healthy before I sell them. This avoids common issues with the species, and helps new keepers have a positive experience. In addition, I go out of my way to answer all questions for new hog keepers, so that through their positive experience, they will go on to purchase more pets, or possibly even breed some of their own. It is through this process of nurturing and growth that our industry stays strong. To that end, I have begun to assemble a video series called The Hog Blog on youtube:
https://www.youtube.com/user/HognoseBlog
It is a work in progress, but I hope that it will someday serve as a useful tool for new keepers and breeders alike.
My animals, and my conduct with customers will always speak for themselves, and no amount of lies piled on to internet forums is going to prevent people from seeing their quality and purchasing them at a reptile show. If anyone doubts the quality of my animals, I encourage you to visit my table at any of the NARBC shows in the upcoming year. Scrutinize my stock, and let me know if you have any concerns.
I want to once again point out that I have never sold a snake or any product to Gregg Madden. I have never bought a snake, or any other product from Gregg Madden. I have never met him in person, and our interactions have been limited to a few, mostly adversarial, exchanges on forums, and PM's. It is for this reason that I filed an official complaint about Gregg's conduct in this thread to the owner of this site. I told him that I was under the impression that the purpose of the BOI was for individuals who have had a business experience with someone in our community to report their impressions of the way that person conducted themselves, good or bad. Since Gregg and I have never done business, I was curious if his inquiries and statements on this thread violated the terms of service. I trust the owner of the site will weigh the facts and decide himself, and I apologize for being forced to bother him with it.
If you are reading this you may be asking yourself why Gregg would be qualified or interested in attacking me, or exposing me as he so dramatically put it. His motivations for making these attacks are firmly grounded in three things.
1. I bought and sold snakes from Justin Mitcham. Gregg, despite his sudden apology, and want for reconciliation posted in this thread, has repeatedly attacked and attempted to discredit Justin on many forums, on many occasions, over many years, and the entire reason for him beginning to attack me was based, as Justin mentioned before, on the box of snakes shipped to one of my customers at Daytona. In the many libelous posts on the forum where Gregg is an admin, he attacks Justin, and compares me to him as if to say being like Justin, or associated with Justin makes one bad. His motivations for flip flopping on that particular point are his own business, but I can't help but feel it had something to do with the emails Justin posted.
2. I have disagreed with him on forums in instances where I thought he was wrong. This sounds small, but if you read some of his exchanges on any of the forums on which he contributes, you will see he reacts quite aggressively to anyone who disagrees with him. (as he has reacted aggressively to the BOI posters in this very thread.)
3. I removed Gregg from a forum on Facebook, because he repeatedly and blatantly violated the terms of the group, and refused to remove or edit his offending posts, and instead chose to escalate them, and personally attack the Administrators.
In the following post I will show you, beyond a reasonable doubt, that Gregg has set about intentionally trying to discredit me, his motivations for doing so, and his use of plausible lies in order to accomplish that goal. I don't have to go any further than this BOI thread to find evidence of it. I have compiled a list of all the false statements he has made here in order of appearance, and I will address them one by one. In a post to follow this one directly. In addition, I will answer all the questions raised by legitimate forum members, and I will add in a few screen grabs and other pertinent information from Facebook, and Kingsnake forums.
If I fall short in any way to back up anything I have said here, please feel free to ask for clarification and further evidence. I am almost certain I will miss something with a post this size.
Because I respect the BOI, and its moderators and members, I will begin by addressing their direct questions first. These questions are all legitimate, despite their originating in libel from Gregg.
I think Mike Curtin summed up the basic questions needing answered in this post in POST #84
Dan:
How many hogs did you sell last year, and how many did you produce?
If by last year, you mean the 2013 season, I produced around 75 hognose on a plan of 300. I sold or traded all but a few. In addition, I sold around 175 hognose from at least 3 other breeders including Justin Mitcham. These numbers arent precise, but they are in the ballpark. The vast majority of those snakes were sold in the 2012 fall, and early 2013 spring seasons, and came from one large breeder who was getting out of the hognose hobby. By selling his snakes, and using the money to buy more, I was able to build up a collection for myself without making a significant investment of my personal capital. I will not mention this breeder, or any other breeders, here, because it doesn't matter, and no one would want to be associated with this circus, I'm sure. The snakes I have received and sold from Justin Mitcham represent a tiny fraction of the snakes I have bred or resold over the last two years. Purchasing this collection, as you will see in a series of screen grabs I will post in a moment, was part of my plan to both stay at home with my kids to save money on daycare, support my family, and get myself back into a financial situation that will allow me to not only repay any money owed from Small Scale Films, but also to get back to doing what I believe my calling is: Making educational, positive films to promote reptile and amphibian conservation, and our herpetocultural industry.
Did you represent all animals as ones you produced personally, or did you credit them you acquired them? Do you have evidence?
I do not label hogs by breeder in my ads, on my website, or at shows. I label them by phenotype, genotype, size and gender. If a customer has a specific inquiry, which they often do, about the origin of the snake, I do not intentionally mislead them to make them think I produced something I didn't. If I produced the snake myself, I will have pictures of the parents, and sometimes the grandparents available. If they inquire, I send pics of the parents (often breeding) and the babies hatching so that they can know the birthdate. In the 2014 season, I would guess there is no hog collection on the planet that is more documented and publicly available. If you would like to see pictures of my snakes mating, laying eggs, eggs hatching, and babies taking their first meals, please hop over to the Hog Blog page on Facebook:
https://www.facebook.com/pages/Hog-Blog/286076341409036
If it comes from someone else, I tell them that, and offer to get more specific information. When I go to a reptile show, for example, and I have say 100 hogs for sale, and 1 or 2 of them were produced by another breeder, I don't overtly list them as such. When you walk into Walmart, you don't get a full list of all the companies a product passed through to get there, you get a price, and a description. I don't know exactly how to prove that. Perhaps someone who has bought snakes from me which I produced or from one of my business partners can chime in? The point is, if my customers care to ask, I willingly volunteer the origin. I am often quite proud to say which partner they come from, because I deal with some of the best breeders in the U.S.
That being said, I MAY have made a mistake somewhere in the past, but it wasn't intentional. I am sure anonymous people have bought snakes from other breeders through me, and not thought to ask who produced them. If anyone who has bought a snake from me would like to find out any information on its origin, I would be happy to help them. Just email If I misled you about their origin in any way, I apologize.
hognoseblog@gmail.com I will very likely remember you snake just from a picture. i spend a lot of time with them getting to know them before I sell them.
Also, since a large part of Gregg's attacks on me, and the only piece of "evidence" he has been able to produce is my conversation with Alicia, I would like to point out that I do not deny selling snakes from Mitcham in our conversation. I simply deny that I am his sole broker, or that most or all of my snakes come from him. (which is the accusation leveled toward me in Gregg's posts on his forum, and the whole reason Alicia and I were even talking.
Gregg posted some small pieces of our conversation which he says are hard proof I lie about the origins of my snakes.
I go on to defend the practice of reselling the snakes in my description of how I distinguish myself from what some people call flippers. If I were denying selling his hogs, why would I defend selling his hogs?
Just for fun, here is an excerpt from a conversation with one of Gregg's fellow moderators on his hog forum, Mads Valentin, where I am, again, defending the practice of buying snakes, adding value, and reselling them. If I deny selling other breeder's hogs, why would I be discussing this with someone Gregg is such good friends with?
I also have a full description of my plan to get my family back together, and get back to making short films, which I sent to Mads. I could post it all here, but it is just my words, and it doesn't really provide any evidence of anything but what I say I'm going to do, not what I have done.
Back to Alicia:
I also ask her directly if she thinks Gregg's accusation that I don't produce any of my own snakes is true. She confirms that my breeding and egg laying pictures are publicly available in this response:
and she reaffirms it here. I also make a really good point about liars. If one person claims that the other produces no snakes, and only brokers, and the other denies it, one is by definition a liar. Gregg knows full well that I breed a ton of hogs. I posted the pics on his own forum. He is simply lying because he is mad at me for the three reasons I listed above.
On the part that Gregg did post:
Alicia is not my customer, and I therefore I have no obligation to explain to her anything, however when she does inquire about specific snakes, I do provide proof of their origin via pictures.
When she asks me about the circumstances of Justin and my deal, I am a bit taciturn, but then I don't think it is appropriate to discuss my business with Justin with a complete stranger without his consent. Could I have been more specific and given her numbers and details? Absolutely, and I can see how Gregg might read this the way he did. Honestly, if I had written that knowing that everyone in the world would have read it, I would have thought it out better. I'm only human, and I have never had casual conversations carried on in private, scrutinized in this way before. Who really prepares for this sort of thing, right?
Justin is, likewise, taciturn, and gives an outline of what actually occurred. It is because of both of us holding back the details from someone who is not buying snakes from us, that this exchange can be misinterpreted. She jumps to the conclusion that I am not being honest, but this isn't true, I'm just not betraying Justin's trust by telling her something I don't think she has any right to know.
How can Justin "supply half the hognose world" and at the same time only sell his animals through me? These contradictions are made clear by the farce created by Gregg.
So we are clear:
I have done business with Justin exactly 3 times.
1. in 2006 I purchased 1.2 extreme line hogs. 1.1 het albino and 0.1 albino
2. In Spring/Winter of 2013 Justin sent me two males on breeding loan. I sent the snakes back to him healthy, and fat, and later sent him babies from three two different clutches which resulted from their breeding.
3. In summer/fall of 2013 Justin, knowing I was having some hard financial times, sent me two boxes of hogs on two occasions. The first containing the adults and morphs listed in this thread. He never charged me a cent, and instead offered to let me sell them and pay them off as I did, taking a small portion of each sale to help me out. The details of this deal are between Justin and I. I see no reason to deny it happened, and no reason to reveal anything to Gregg because he makes wild accusations about something he has no knowledge of.
I will say this, the snakes I received from Justin were high quality, and I highly recommend purchasing from him. He always tries to do the right thing, and is an extremely experienced breeder.
Also, the total number of snakes of Justins that I have sold represents a tiny tiny fraction of the hogs I have produced, sold, or brokered in my 15-16 years working with the species.
How were you able to spend $10,000.00 on animals during the time you claimed you had no money to re-pay existing debt to a number of people in our hobby who had trusted you for a product you had not provided?
The statement I made to Justin, offering to purchase a group for 10,000.00 was made, as he email clearly shows, BEFORE I had begun to sell for the season, and before my double clutches had even hatched. I am a positive guy, and I'm always expecting the best outcome. I had the best hognose breeding season of my life this year with well over 300 eggs having been laid at that point. I was sure I would be in great financial shape shortly. I talk in the email about the shows I will be attending in the future. I made a business plan based on my projected earnings and thought I could invest a further 10,000 into wholesale to extend my season, and help myself financially. I had a bit less luck with gender ratios, and proving out pos hets in test crosses, so the snakes I produced, while numerous, were not as valuable as I had hoped.
A better question might be: Did you spend $10,000.00 on hogs from Justin in 2014 or ever? The answer would be: no My projections turned out to be incorrect, and I ended up satisfying my debt to Justin by sending him animals instead of money. The other snakes I have received from him have been paid for through their sales, and not out of my pocket.
There is absolutely no reason to assume that I was not planning to repay the Small Scale Debt by reading that email. Whether or not I was, is not made clear by that conversation. (Of course I was, but neither myself, nor Gregg can prove or disprove that.)
Why have you referred to Small Scale Films as not for profit, when it is not registered as such?
I filed Small Scale Films 501c3 applications through Legal Zoom, and paid for the legal fees out of my own pocket. Small Scale films was incorporated in the state of Kansas, and was legally able to receive tax deductible donations. Zero percent of the money taken in by Small Scale Films was spent on salaries or expenses, and all went to fulfill the charter of the company. Some of Small Scale's assets, in the form of a few dozen t-shirts, were transferred to the Texas Rattlesnake Festival. It is customary and legal when a non-profit corporation lapses to transfer any assets to another charitable organization. I have since let the company lapse. I will dig up some paperwork to support this.
Those are the main questions asked by the legitimate BOI contributors here, but I would like to finish by anticipating a further question you might have:
Why, if I produced so many snakes this season, have I not put that money toward refunding donations?
The answer is simple, the hognose breeding and selling business I run supports my family. It is my sole source of income, and it is part of a two year plan (which because of my lackluster season in 2013 is becoming a three year plan) to get my family back to some semblance of economic stability, and get back to making conservation films.
I will not go into details of my financial situation, or my quality of life here, because it is no one's business, and some of it is a bit embarrassing, but I will say that I cannot sacrifice my children's needs for the needs of Small Scale. I made that mistake once before, and I owe it to them to always put them first.
I could, for example, sell my house, and pay back the handful of donors today, but I am not taking my kids' house away to pay for my mistakes. I know that I owe that money, and I know that before I do anything I will have to repay it, and I have vowed to. Gregg is in no position to say I won't.
Likewise, I could sell my breeder hogs, and pay that money back today, but I would be undermining next years' babies, which will put food on the table for my family.
I don't know what else to do other than to pledge I will make it right as soon as I can. Maybe I will have a stellar hog season next year, or maybe something else will come along sooner to make it happen fast, but I have learned not to make promises I don't know I can keep. Again, if anyone would like to discuss small scale films, my snakes or anything else, I am always available.
Dan Krull
913-709-5865
In my next post, I will respond to each and every one of Gregg's attacks and questions using the post numbers.