This is article is a little long and covers 1991 t0 2001. I'm guessing the fatalities by venomous snakes includes captive kept animals as well as wild bites. You will need to view the original article to see all the tables I only included one table. "Other Reptile" has killed more people over 65 than snakes, 59 to 12 in 10 years. I'm at a loss what the "Other" might be, since there are 15 fatalities in the North-East and 41 in the Mid-West, I haven't seen an alligator in the Ohio river for some time now.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Wilderness and Environmental Medicine: Vol. 16, No. 2, pp. 67–74.
Animal-Related Fatalities in the United States—An Update
Ricky L. Langley, MD, MPH
From the North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services, Division of Public Health, Raleigh, NC
Objective.—To evaluate the causes of human fatalities in the United States from 1991 to 2001 that were caused by venomous and nonvenomous animal encounters exclusive of zoonotic infections or animal-vehicle collisions.
Methods.—An inquiry of CDC Wonder, a database for epidemiologic research, was used to provide information on animal-related fatalities on the basis of ICD-9 and ICD-10 codes.
Results.—From 1991 to 2001, 1943 persons died in the United States after venomous and nonvenomous animal encounters. An average of 177 fatalities per year were recorded. Venomous animal encounters were responsible for 39% of the fatalities. White males appear to be the group most likely to die from an encounter. Most fatalities occurred in the southern United States.
Conclusions.—Although the average number of fatalities from animal encounters has increased compared with the previous decade, the death rate has remained essentially unchanged. The medical and financial costs from both fatal and nonfatal animal encounters have a significant impact on public health.
Key Words: snake, spider, fatalities, animal, venomous, nonvenomous
Introduction Return to Top
Injuries and illnesses from animal encounters continue to be a major public health problem.1–3 Animals can cause injuries by various mechanisms that include bite, sting, crush, gore, stomp, buck off, fall on, peck, or scratch. Millions of injuries, hundreds of thousands of emergency department visits, and thousands of hospitalizations, at a cost of hundreds of millions of dollars, occur yearly because of animal encounters.3,4 Fortunately, the majority of such injuries are minor. However, many injuries remain undocumented and many people die, primarily in third-world countries, before receiving adequate medical care.5 This study is an update of fatal injuries resulting from animal encounters in the United States between 1991 and 2001. Fatalities from zoonotic infections and animal-vehicle collisions are not included in this report.
Methods Return to Top
All human fatalities and causes of death are reported annually to the National Center for Health Statistics. CDC Wonder (
www.cdcwonder.gov), an online database for epidemiologic research developed by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, was used to query data from the Center. The total number of fatalities from animal encounters in the United States for the time period 1991 to 2001 was obtained.
The fatalities from 1991 to 1998 were coded by the International Classification of Diseases, 9th edition (ICD-9). From 1999 to 2001, the International Classification of Diseases, 10th edition (ICD-10) was used. There are slight differences in how injuries are classified. The ICD-9 uses external cause-of-injury codes (E-codes) 905 and 906 to identify the animal-related fatalities (Table 1 ). E-code 905 includes the release of venom through fangs, spines, tentacles, or other venom apparatus and chemicals released by animals and insects. This category excludes the eating of poisonous plants or animals. Other animal-related injuries are classified as E-906. This classification excludes poisoning and toxic reactions caused by venomous animals, road vehicle accidents involving animals, and tripping or falling over an animal. ICD-10 uses different codes. External causes of death use V-, W-, X-, and Y-codes. For animal-related injuries, W- and X-codes are used (Table 1 ).
Data were evaluated by race, sex, age, and region of country. Race was classified as white, black, and “other race.” Age was categorized into the following groups for analysis: 0 to 4, 5 to 9, 10 to 19, 20 to 64, and 65 years and older. Regions of the country were categorized as West (Alaska, Arizona, California, Colorado, Hawaii, Idaho, Montana, Nevada, New Mexico, Oregon, Utah, Washington, Wyoming), Midwest (Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Michigan, Minnesota, Missouri, Nebraska, North Dakota, Ohio, South Dakota, Wisconsin), South (Alabama, Arkansas, Delaware, District of Columbia, Florida, Georgia, Kentucky, Mississippi, North Carolina, Oklahoma, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, Virginia, West Virginia), and Northeast (Connecticut, Maine, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Vermont).
Rates of animal-related fatalities were calculated for each category defined by E-, W-, and X-codes. Rates are based on the year 2000 United States population. Excluded from this study are fatalities from collisions between animals and vehicles, from animals being ridden, and from zoonotic infections.
ICD-10 does not have a category for “other specified animal.” Instead, ICD-10 includes separate categories for alligators, other mammals, marine animals, and other reptiles. These are combined with the ICD-9 category (E906.8) of “other specified animal” injury for purposes of analysis.
Results Return to Top
Between 1991 and 2001, 1943 persons were reported fatally injured by animals. An average of approximately 177 fatalities occurred annually, with a range of 152 in 1994 to 212 in 2000. The total number of fatalities during this time period was 759 for venomous animals (average of 69 per year, range 57–81) and 1184 for nonvenomous animals (average of 107.6 per year, range 78– 149). For every year, nonvenomous animal-related fatalities exceeded those caused by venomous animals.
ANIMAL
An average of 177 fatalities per year occurred from both venomous and nonvenomous animals. Animal-related fatalities under the category “other specified animal” (E906.8) comprised 43.5% of all reported fatalities, followed by hornets, bees, and wasps at 27.4% (Table 2 ). When evaluated by venomous or nonvenomous categories, venomous animals caused 39.1% and nonvenomous animals caused 60.9% of the fatalities. Of the venomous animals, hornets, bees, and wasps caused the majority of fatalities (70.2%) (Table 3 ). The average number of fatalities per year was 48 for hymenoptera, 6 for spiders, and 5 for snakes. Of the nonvenomous category, animal-related fatalities under the category “other specified animal” comprised the majority of the fatalities (71.5%) (Table 4 ). Among identified nonvenomous animals, dogs caused the majority of fatalities (about 19 per year). Death rates per million persons per year were calculated for venomous animals (0.256), nonvenomous animals (0.399), and all animals combined (0.655) (Table 5 ).
SEX AND RACE
Males accounted for 72.4% of the cases and females 27.6% (Table 6 ). For venomous animal attacks, males accounted for 74.6% of the injuries and females 25.4%. For nonvenomous animal attacks, males accounted for 70.9% of the injuries and females 29.1%. The overall death rate was 0.969 per million per year for males and 0.354 per million per year for females. Males had a 2.9 times greater risk of venomous animal-related fatality and a 2.4 times greater risk of nonvenomous animal-related fatality than did females.
By race, whites had a higher percentage (91%) and higher rate of fatalities compared with the other racial groups. The death rate per million per year was 0.726 for whites, 0.317 for blacks, and 0.324 for other races. The percentage of venomous animal-related fatalities was 91.7% for whites, 7.5% for blacks, and 0.8% for other races. The percentage of nonvenomous animal-related fatalities was 91.4% for whites, 3.3% for blacks, and 5.3% for other races.
AGE
Five age categories were created for analysis of the data (Table 7 ): 0 to 4 years (7.8%), 5 to 9 years (4.1%), 10 to 19 years (5%), 20 to 64 years (53.4%), and 65 years and older (29.5%). The elderly appear to be overrepresented in the fatalities caused by hymenoptera, dogs, other specified animals, other mammals, and other reptiles. The youngest individuals are overrepresented in the fatalities caused by dogs.
REGION
CDC Wonder categorizes the United States into 4 regions for data analysis. Overall, percentages for fatalities were 45.4% in the South, 11% in the Northeast, 18.8% in the West, and 24.8% in the Midwest. The percentages for venomous animal-related injuries were 52.2% in the South, 14.5% in the Northeast, 12.9% in the West, and 20.4% in the Midwest. The percentages for nonvenomous animal-related injuries were 41% in the South, 8.9% in the Northeast, 22.6% in the West, and 27.5% in the Midwest (Table 8 ).
Discussion Return to Top
Encounters with animals cause hundreds of fatalities, millions of nonfatal injuries, and cost hundreds of millions of dollars annually in the United States.4 In addition to inflicting traumatic injuries, animals transmit numerous zoonotic infections. Thousands of cases of Lyme disease and West Nile virus occur in the United States yearly and are responsible for many fatalities and cases of chronic illness.6 Zoonotic infections are responsible for hundreds of fatalities each year in the United States.
Excluding motor vehicle or animal-ridden events and zoonotic infections, animals caused a yearly average of 177 fatalities in the United States from 1991 to 2001. Although this is an increase from the 157 average fatalities reported from 1979 to 1990, the US population has risen and the fatality rate remains essentially the same as in 1979 to 1990 (6.55 vs 6.57 fatalities per 10 million population). Studies have shown an additional 200 fatalities occur yearly from deer-vehicle collisions in the United States.7,8
Venomous animals caused an average of 69 fatalities per year from 1991 to 2001, compared with 46 per year from 1950 to 1959 and 60 per year from 1979 to 1990 (Table 9 ). Parrish9 found a higher percentage of fatalities from venomous snakes, spiders, and scorpions, compared to Langley and Morrow10 and the present study that found a higher percentage attributed to hymenoptera. Interestingly, spider-related fatalities surpassed snake-related fatalities from 1991 to 2001. This may be because of increasing destruction of snake habitat and lower snake population numbers.11,12 The death rate from venomous animals was 0.256 per million for the present study compared with 0.251 from 1979 to 1990 and 0.28 from 1950 to 1959.
Nonvenomous animals caused more fatalities than did venomous animals. In previous reports, as reflected by location of injury, most nonvenomous injuries are probably caused by farm animals.10 CDC Wonder does not provide the location of injury. In a study of nonvenomous animal-related fatalities in Sweden from 1975 to 1984, horses and cattle caused 93% of the fatalities.13 Some fatalities from nonvenomous arthropods may be a result of anaphylaxis after a bite.14
Males are more likely to die from venomous and nonvenomous animal-related injuries than are females.10,15 This probably reflects the greater exposure of males to outdoor activities such as farming and hunting. Some studies suggest that males may be more likely to develop a severe reaction after a bee sting.16–18 Males may also have more underlying diseases, such as coronary atherosclerosis, which may be a significant risk factor for a major adverse event after an insect sting.19,20
Whites appear to have a greater risk of fatality from an animal encounter than do blacks or other races. Reasons are not entirely clear, but whites are more likely to be hunters (97% are white) and farm operators (97%), thus increasing their risk of exposure to large farm animals as well as wild animals.21,22 The numbers of Hispanic farm workers are increasing,21 which may partially explain why other races are more likely to be killed by nonvenomous animals than are blacks.
Children younger than 10 years and adults ages 65 and older appear to be at increased risk of death from dog attacks. In 2001, an estimated 368245 persons were treated for dog bite injuries.3 The injury rate was highest for children ages 5 to 9 years. For children younger than 15 years, the injury rate was significantly higher for boys (293.2 per 100000) than for girls (216.7 per 100000). The rate for persons ages 15 years and older was not significantly different (102.9 vs 88).3 In this study, males were 1.8 times more likely to be killed by dogs. The elderly, who comprise approximately 13% of the population,23 also were more likely to die from hymenoptera stings and “other” animal categories. Fatalities from hymenoptera may be because of increased likelihood of serious underlying disease, such as cardiovascular disease. It is not clear why the elderly are more likely to die from “other” animals, but the elderly are more likely to die when involved in traumatic events.24
By region of the United States, the South has the largest percentage of animal-related fatalities. Part of this may be because of warmer weather increasing insect populations in the South and colder weather limiting the spread of venomous animals, such as fire ants, to higher latitudes. Alligators and several species of venomous snakes are more likely to be found in the South. Warmer temperatures in the South may also increase the likelihood that children will more likely play outdoors year round, thus increasing their chance of exposure to animals. Studies show that species richness in human pathogens is correlated with latitude.25
The major weakness of this study is that no individual death certificates or reports were available to verify fatalities reported. For example, fatalities from centipedes or tropical millipedes are essentially unheard of; however, 5 were recorded during this time period. Although sex, age range, and the states where the fatalities occurred are available, the actual cases cannot be verified as attributable to centipedes. It is interesting that no case reports from these centipede-related fatalities have been reported in PubMed (
www.pubmed.gov), although a recent study suggests possible myocardial ischemia after a nonfatal centipede sting as a mechanism that could lead to death.26
A weakness of the International Classification of Disease reporting system is that many large animals such as bears, sharks, cows, and horses are all included in the “other specified animal” category. Therefore, the actual number of fatalities caused by a specific species is not known for many animals. Future editions should consider adding more categories of specific animals. CDC Wonder does not provide information on the location of death and activity at the time of injury; however, this information would be useful in developing education programs on prevention of animal-related injuries.
As previously noted, other animal-related fatalities are not included in this study. Up to 200 fatalities per year may result from vehicle-animal collisions.7,8 Also, fatalities resulting from falling off a ridden animal are classified differently and are not included in this study. These accidents are classified as E-code 828. From 1991 to 1998, an average of 88 fatalities per year were attributed to riding an animal, usually a horse. Including these numbers and the few cases of unknown fatalities possibly caused by anaphylactic reactions to animal stings27 and motor vehicle accidents as a result of swerving to miss an animal on the highway, it is likely that 500 to 600 fatalities per year can be attributed to animal-human interactions, not including infections transmitted by animals.
It is possible to decrease fatalities and serious injuries from animal attacks. Children should be educated about the potential danger of animals, especially dogs. Helmets should be worn when riding horses.28,29 Individuals with a history of systemic reactions from insect stings should carry epinephrine kits.18 Hikers and campers should check with rangers before embarking in bear and cougar territories. Swimmers should avoid areas where sharks are known to frequent, especially during times of the day when sharks are most likely to feed.30 Wild animals should not be fed, for this tends to make them less fearful of humans. If injured by a wild animal, an individual should seek medical treatment. The use of insect repellants is effective in preventing many types of insect bites and stings.31 Also, methods to prevent deer-vehicle collisions are being evaluated.32
Several hundred fatalities occur in the United States yearly from encounters with animals. Many, if not most, of these fatalities can be prevented. Advances in antivenom therapy and hymenoptera desensitization therapy will likely prevent fatalities and lessen adverse effects from use of these products. Continuing education of farmers and farm families about the hazards of working with large animals is important. Advances in automobile-detection technology and use of fencing in areas of high animal density should decrease animal-vehicle collisions. National parks, which protect our natural resources and can serve as a haven to protect endangered species, may offer opportunities for viewing wildlife. Guided tours can describe the importance of various ecosystems to visitors while allowing them to view potentially dangerous animals in a controlled environment.
References Return to Top
1. Moore RM, Zehmer RB, Moulthrop JI, Parker RL. Surveillance of animal-bite cases in the United States, 1971– 1972. Arch Environ Health. 1977;32:267–270. [PubMed Citation]
2. Beck AM, Jones BA. Unreported dog bites in children. Public Health Rep. 1985;100:315–320. [PubMed Citation]
3. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention., Nonfatal dog bite-related injuries treated in hospital emergency departments—United States, 2001. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep. 2003;52,605–610.
4. Overall KL, Love M. Dog bites to humans—demography, epidemiology, injury, and risk. J Am Vet Med Assoc. 2001;218:1923–1934. [PubMed Citation]
5. Chippaux JP. Snake-bites: appraisal of the global situation. Bull World Health Organ. 1998;176:515–524.
6. Murray JL, Lopez AD, eds. World Health Organization. The Global Burden of Disease: A Comprehensive Assessment of Mortality and Disability From Diseases, Injuries, and Risk Factors in 1990 and Projected to 2020. Cambridge, MA: Harvard School of Public Health; 1996.
7. Conover MR. Monetary and intangible valuation of deer in the United States. Wildl Soc Bull. 1995;25:298–305.
8. Danielson BJ, Hubbard MW., A literature review for assessing the status of current methods of reducing deer-vehicle collisions. 1998. Available at:
http://www.dot.state.ia.us/crashanal...yfordotdnr.pdf. Accessed July 7, 2004.
9. Parrish HM. Analysis of 460 fatalities from venomous animals in the United States. Am J Med Sci. 1963;245:129–141. [PubMed Citation]
10. Langley RL, Morrow WE. Deaths resulting from animal attacks in the United States. Wilderness Environ Med. 1997;8:8–16. [PubMed Citation]
11. Sprott P, Mazzotti F., Habitat loss, Florida's changing landscape: upland forest. University of Florida Cooperative Extension Service. Available at: edis.ifas.ufl.edu/BODY_UW160. Accessed July 19, 2004.
12. Mirtschin P., Dangerous snakes of Australia. Available at: homepages.ihug.com.au/~venomsup/dangeroussnakesofsa/snakesindecline.html. Accessed July 19, 2004.
13. Ornehult L, Eriksson A, Bjornstig U. Fatalities caused by nonvenomous animals: a ten-year summary from Sweden. Accid Anal Prev. 1989;21:377–398. [PubMed Citation]
14. Moffitt JE, Vernarske D, Goddard J, Yates AB, deShazo RD. Allergic reactions to Triatoma bites. Ann Allergy Asthma Immunol. 2003;91:122–128. [PubMed Citation]
15. Mueller UR., Insect Sting Allergy: A Clinical Picture, Diagnosis and Treatment. New York, NY: Gustav Fisher Verlag; 1990.
16. Charpin D, Birnbaum J, Vervloet D. Epidemiology of hymenoptera allergy. Clin Exp Allergy. 1994;24:1010–1015. [PubMed Citation]
17. Leveau P. Risk factors for allergy to hymenoptera stings. Allerg Immunol (Paris). 1993;25:224–226.
18. Warpinski JR, Bush RK. Stinging insect allergy. J Wilderness Med. 1990;1:249–257.
19. National Center for Health Statistics. Coronary heart disease incidence by sex: United States, 1971–1987. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep. 1992;41:526–529.
20. Harvey P, Sperber S, Kette F, Heddle RJ, Roberts-Thompson PJ. Bee-sting mortality in Australia. Med J Aust. 1984;140:209–211. [PubMed Citation]
21. National Agricultural Statistics Service for U.S. Agriculture., Available at:
www.usda.gov/nass. Accessed July 7, 2004.
22. Phelps N., A dying sport. Available at:
www.fundforanimals.org/uploads/adyingsport2.htm. Accessed July 14, 2004.
23. Holmes JF., United States population: a profile of America's diversity—the view from the Census Bureau, 1998. In: The World Almanac and Book of Facts 1999. Mahwah, NJ: Primedia References Inc; 1998.
24. Hannan EL, Waller CH, Farrell LS, Rosati C. Elderly trauma in patients in New York state: 1994–1998. J Trauma. 2004;56:1297–1304. [PubMed Citation]
25. Guernier V, Hochberg ME, Guegan J. Ecology drives the worldwide distribution of human diseases. PLoS Biol. 2004;2:740–746.
26. Ozsarac M, Karcioglu O, Ayrik C, Somuncu F, Gumrukcu S. Acute coronary ischemia following centipede envenomation: case report and review of the literature. Wilderness Environ Med. 2004;15:109–112. [PubMed Citation]
27. Schwartz HJ, Sutheimer C, Gauerke MB, Yunginger JW. Hymenoptera venom-specific IgE antibodies in post-mortem sera from victims of sudden, unexpected death. Clin Allergy. 1988;18:461–468. [PubMed Citation]
28. Griffen M, Boulanger BR, Kearney PA, Tsuei B, Ochoa J. Injury during contact with horses: recent experience with 75 patients at a level 1 trauma center. South Med J. 2002;95:441–445. [PubMed Citation]
29. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Horseback-riding-associated traumatic brain injuries—Oklahoma, 1992–1994. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep. 1996;45:209–211.
30. Florida Museum of Natural History., Reducing the risk. Available at:
www.flmnh.ufl.edu/fish/sharks/ISAF/ISAF.htm ISAF.htm. Accessed July 14, 2004.
31. National Center for Infectious Diseases., Protection against mosquitoes and other arthropods. Available at:
www.cdc.gov/travel/bugs.htm. Accessed July 12, 2004.
32. Hedlund JH, Curtis PD, Curtis G, Williams AF. Methods to reduce traffic crashes involving deer: what works and what does not. Traffic Inj Prev. 2004;6:122–131.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Tables Return to Top
Table 1. Code and category of animal-related fatalities
Table 2. Rank order of animal-related fatalities in the United States (1991–2001)
Table 3. Venomous animal-related fatalities in the United States (1991–2001)
Table 4. Nonvenomous animal-related fatalities in the United States (1991–2001)
Table 5. Animal-related fatalities in the United States (1991–2001)
Table 6. Animal-related fatalities in the United States by sex and race (1991–2001)
Table 7. Age (years) and animal-related fatalities in the United States (1991–2001)
Table 8. Animal-related fatalities in the United States by region of country (1991–2001)
Table 9. Percentage of venomous animal-related fatalities in the United States
Corresponding author: Ricky Langley, MD, MPH, North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services, Division of Public Health, 1912 Mail Service Center, Raleigh, NC 27699-1912 (E-mail:
rick.langley@ncmail.net)
http://www.wemjournal.org/wmsonline/...e=02&page=0067
Linear Mode
