I bought some baby leopard geckos from him recently. I didnt have the greatest of experiences but it wasnt horrible.
Things to think about/watch out for:
He buys everything wholesale and ships via Express mail with the postal service. I thought I was getting my lizards overnight but turned out to be second day delivery. This freaked me out a bit because it was my first purchase online and I was scared to death that my lizards would arrive dead. The thing is with Fed-Ex/UPS is that they are overnight guaranteed. With the postal service it is next day OR second day. Im not sure that Salty City even realizes this himself...
He doesnt have any kind of live arrival guarantee that I know of...
I also asked him what kind of albino leopard gecko I was getting and he didnt seem to know, I dont think he understood what I was talking about. He responded by telling me what he was selling which just struck me as odd... For those who dont know there are 3 different genetic strains of albino in leopard geckos. They are not genetically compatible so it is fairly important to know what you have if you want to make more albinos
Some GOOD things about him:
He responded to my emails quickly, on average he got back to me within 2-4 hours.
He was also very nice and polite to deal with, even when I was a little frantic.
Overall I would probably rate my dealings with Salty City as a 7 out of 10.
I hope this helps!