OK, here is the first 'installment' of the facts that led to the closing of one of the PetCo stores in my area. Note in the correspondence that the responses from PetCorp clearly state at the bottom, "PETCO Animal Supplies, Inc." and NOT Petco Pet Store, Inc. Please try to withold your comments and conclusions until I get all the information posted....
I had been online with Trace from Gexfiles discussing Petco and 2 sick baby Leopard Geckos I had “rescued” from one of my local stores. She had been working on several legitimate and documented cases of cryptosporidia from Leopard Geckos that were purchased from various Petco stores in the USA, and wanted my input. She had been in contact with someone at ‘PetCorp’, and she provided me with the name and email of the supervisor she was dealing with. Needless to say, I was terrified and sent this self-explanatory letter:
Subj: To Kim Sherman, re: sick Leopard Geckos
Date: 3/8/01
To:
customersatisfaction@petco.com
Dear Ms. Sherman,
As a reputable breeder of Leopard Geckos in California, I am compelled to write you in regard to my personal experiences with one of your Petco stores and their practices in keeping, feeding, and handling of the reptiles, Leopard Geckos specifically. I was referred to you by a Petco employee, and wish to state that the intent of this communication is non-confrontational, but rather to increase the awareness and level of education that I believe is necessary to provide the proper husbandry and health care for these creatures. I am in no way in competition with Petco for sales of Leopard Geckos, but the existing conditions are extremely urgent.
Approximately 6 months ago, I was in the *****, CA. store and visited the reptile tanks as I always do. What I saw was appalling, and sickened me to the point of tears. There was a small tank enclosure of approximately 12"x12" containing 8-12 juvenile Leopard Geckos that were so sick and emaciated that I was speechless with despair. One of them was dead and had a cricket eating its eye. The tank was full of feces, most of which was greenish, mucous-laden diarrhea. I immediately brought it to the attention of the store manager, who replied, "This is the way they come. What am I supposed to with them?"
I was outraged, and asked why the store had them on display for everyone to see in that condition. I asked if they had been seen or treated by a Veterinarian. The response I got was that Petco does not want the expense of Veterinary bills, and when the lizards die they just return them and get replacements. I asked where they get their Leopard Geckos, and she said she did not know. I asked her who I should talk to regarding this, and was told there was an ‘800’ number to call.
That experience actually traumatized me, and I cried when I got home. I called the Petco "800" number for customer service and spoke to ****, one of your representatives who said she would check into the situation, but I did not receive any response or follow-up.
I never returned to that store until last Friday, March 2, 2001. Again, I went to the reptile tanks and this is what I observed. There were two 12"X12" tank enclosures with about 20 Leopard Geckos. Both tanks had adults, juveniles, and hatchlings in them mixed together, and several of them were emaciated. The tanks were full of feces, the water bowls were slimy with dead crickets, and when I asked if someone would accompany me to the tanks, an employee named ***** opened the door in order to access the area behind the tanks. I brought to her attention the condition of the geckos & tanks and the fact that hatchlings should never be housed with adults.
She allowed me to sort the babies and adults into separate tanks, and to my shock and surprize, a good-sized Sand Skink came up out of the sand right in the midst of the hatchlings and began to feed on one of them. I almost fainted. When I asked ***** why the Skink was in that tank, and she advised me that taking care of the lizards wasn't her job. She then asked me if I intended to buy any of the geckos, and if so, to hurry up because she had to leave to pick up her daughter from school. Then I did what no responsible breeder should do, and bought two of the little babies out of concern and compassion. I took fecal samples to my Vet, but nothing could be accurately diagnosed.
By Tuesday, March 6, 2001, one of the babies died, never eating since I got it. I had been dropper-feeding them with baby food mixed with Ensure, Pedialite, and supplements. My Vet felt it could have been due to stress from being kept with so many others, including adults and a large Skink, and it appeared to have been sand-impacted from consuming the large grains of CalciSand in the tank when striking at crickets.
I returned the dead baby to that store yesterday, Wednesday, March 7 and ***** the store manager was there. I spoke to her at length, and she also said the reptiles come in sick and told me she would find out who their source was. She then immediately got the young fellow who is responsible for the reptiles and asked me to show them what was going on in the tanks and with the Leopard Geckos. I was all too thrilled to do so, and wound up spending about a half-hour educating them about the care, housing, and behavior of these little creatures. They were very receptive, and the young man asked for my business card in case he had any questions. I pointed out the sick lizards, and he promptly removed them into a separate container. I informed him that when the Sand Skink eats the babies in the tank and they were infected with something, the Skink most likely would become infected as well. I would like to point out however, that he did not wash or sanitize his hands after handling the sick ones, and said that the geckos had not been fed in several days because there was a problem with their shipment of crickets.
Not only as a breeder of these gentle, beautiful lizards, but a concerned lover of all animals, I find this practice of "husbandry" appalling, pitiful, inhumane, and utterly unacceptable. Something MUST be done to educate the employees, management and corporate decision-makers of Petco to provide the proper care these animals deserve, and discontinue buying sick and infected animals from the vendor sources themselves. It is a health risk of epidemic proportion, and completely unfair and cruel to the animals and their owners who love them.
I am willing to volunteer my time for training in your store(s) locally in the proper basic care and husbandry of these animals, and am looking forward to discussing this with the management of PetCo. I sincerely appreciate your indulgence and immediate action with this urgent matter.
Respectfully,
Marcia McGuiness
"The Lizard Lady"
LizardLady2001@aol.com
(925) 755-3113
__________________________________________________ _
The following day, Ms. Sherman from Petco called me and advised me that she had forwarded my letter to members of management who handle these problems, and I should be contacted within the next day or two. In the meantime, the second baby I’d “rescued” had died also. I spoke once again to Trace from Gexfiles, for information on another reptile breeder who was involved in an issue with Petco, and told me she would let this other breeder know, and have him contact me. Some time passed, and I sent this follow-up to Petco:
Subj: To Kim Sherman re: sick/dying Leopard Geckos
Date: 3/22/01
To:
customersatisfaction@petco.com,
trace@gexfiles.com
Dear Ms. Sherman,
I wrote you an email letter on 3/8/01 regarding my experience with the Petco store in *****, CA and the deplorable conditions in which the Leopard Geckos were kept, and would like to advise you of the fact that one of the two babies I "rescued" had died an agonizing death due to what is likely stress and/or sand impaction. I exchanged the dead baby for a replacement that seemed to be healthy and fairly well nourished.
You called me on 3/9/01 and advised me that you had forwarded my letter to the department that investigates this type of practice within the Petco stores, and they would be contacting me. I have yet to hear that this situation has been followed-up on. I cannot emphasize how critical this problem is enough.
In the meantime, I wanted to provide you with an update on the status of the two babies (1 original, 1 replacement) from the *****, CA store I have had in my care. I had a veterinarian do a fecal examination of both of them, and it tested positive for Coccidia, a very serious and highly contagious parasitic infection. If you provide me with a mailing address, I will be happy to send you a copy of the report. Neither of these little babies have eaten since I purchased them, and I have been meticulously hand-feeding them 2X a day from an eye-dropper for over two weeks. Their feces is still runny and smells of infection. The surviving baby I purchased first continues to regurgitate its food, is dehydrated, and has become seriously emaciated to the point of death, and I expect it will die within a few days. The replacement baby seems to be stabilizing, although it still refuses to eat. I have been treating both of them with medication, (Albon) and an appetite stimulant.
Ms. Sherman, something MUST be done about this! I would like to provide photographs of these babies to demonstrate the severity of their condition, although they are graphic and extremely disturbing. Perhaps this is what is necessary to cause Petco and its corporate decision-makers to realize just how these animals suffer by the ignorance and apathy that is practiced in the ***** store. As a reptile breeder and animal lover, it is heartbreaking for me to witness this result of what I consider to be criminal inhumanity to these beautiful, gentle little creatures. This does not even account for the emotional sadness and despair it creates for us who love and care for our geckos. Animals kept under these conditions in plain sight in a store that has hundreds of customers only reinforces the myths that reptiles are literally “NON-PETS” and do not deserve the care, treatment and conditions that other animals do.
Please advise me of the status of this case, and to whom I should send the photographs and pathology report as compelling evidence of the severity of this problem within this local Petco store.
Respectfully,
Marcia McGuiness
"The Lizard Lady"
lizardlady2001@aol.com
(925) 755-3113
__________________________________________________ __
A week went by with no response from Ms. Sherman, but I received the following forwarded email from Trace:
Subj: PetCo letter from Tom Morris
Date: 3/28/01 6:21:12 AM Pacific Standard Time
From:
trace@gexfiles.com (Tracy Willis)
To:
LizardLady2001@aol.com
Hey Marcia,
I wanted to forward you the letter that Tom Morris sent to PetCo yesterday. It is heartbreaking to say the least and I pray that he will get his justice for this. I began this passionate mission to stop the abuse and crypto infected leos because of him, but it was others who pressed it on.
Talk to you soon!
Trace
----------
From: "Thomas Morris" <vanyul@hotmail.com>
Date: Tue, 27 Mar 2001 14:42:52 -0800
To:
trace@eyesurf.com
Subject: Letter to Petco
Here is a copy of the letter that I sent to PetCo. I did put in a list at the bottom of the ones that died. I also fibbed a tiny bit as that I put Mr. Biggles and Stumblia on it because they will never be able to be put in with other geckos and from a business standpoint, essentially died. But the rest of the list are ones that I did lose. Let me know what you think....
In January of 2000, my girlfriend found some leopard geckos at a local PetCo Clackamas store, 82nd Ave, Portland, OR), that she thought I would like for my birthday. They were a little skinny but oterwise appeared normal. What she didn't know was that they had been infected with cryptoporidia from other leopard geckos housed with them. And so began my nightmare.
Soon all of my other leos began to get skinny as well. They all began to have diarreah. After the pair that we had got from PetCo had infected the rest of my breeders, they had died. Soon, one by one, my breeders seemed to starve to death. They were all eating but still starving to death. Towards the end, it was pretty horrible. They would begin to go into seizures. It was enough to make both me and my girlfriend ball like little babies everytime it happened (which was MANY). The PetCo store would only do a replacement of the geckos. They replaced the two I got from them with two more infected geckos!
Repeated trips to the vet produced nothing more than large vet bills. Fecal tests showed nothing. The vet said that the only way to diagnose the problem was through an expensive necropsy. By this time, I had started paying a lot of money to my vet to euthanize the animals when they got close to the end. but he said that uthanizing would foul a necropsy so I had to let one suffer to the end before a necropsy could be done! The unfortunate geckos name was Smootches. Watching her die was enough that I still cry everytime I think about it. Everyone of these animals was like family to us.
We took her body to Oregon State University in Corvallis, OR by car because the two hour drive was the only way to get her body there fast enough to perform the necropsy (my boss was very nice about the time off of work because he knew about what was going on). When the results were in, my vet asked me to come in and told me it was crypto. He explained what it was and that it had come from infected geckos. The only new geckos I had purchased within the last year and a half were the ones from PetCo. He said due to the gestation period etc, that it only takes weeks to show symptoms. This let me know where it had come from.
I immediately went back to the store. I spoke with the manager and she showed me a leo that they had had in the back for months. He was dying but had been fighting crypto for months. I let them know what he had and that he needed too be destroyed. They said OK, but when I returned to the store weeks later, he was back in the display case infecting newly arrived hatchling leos!!! I was sick. This means that MANY infected leos were sold through this store over the course of months. I finally just stopped going into PetCo altogether over it. Before this, I had spent over $3000.00 at that store in one year! This was like a slap in the face!
I then contacted David Chan who was the regional manager. I explained to him what had happened. He said that he would peplace or refund all of the adults that I had lost and pay for vet bills, necropsies, etc. and would look into changing suppliers. I told him at this point that I was still infected and that until the "death toll" was finalized, I would not feel right having him pay for geckos that were still alive. He said OK. I lost his number and the manager I was working with was moved to another store. I wasn't able to get back ahold of him to get this resolved.
Since then I have recieved emails from people ALL OVER THE U.S. who have gotten crypto infected leos from PetCo and had to try to explain to their children why their leo died such a horrible death. They go back to PetCo, only to have the animal replaced with another infected animal. If it were not for my work schedule, I would probably stand outside of your store with a sign over this whole incident. To big pet stores, these animals are nothing more than an inventory item. To us they are FAMILY! I am no tree hugging animal extremist by any means, but these animals are living creatures. And if you ever have to watch one of them die from this, let alone the sheer number of my animals I haved watched die from it, you would never again be the same!
All of the animals I lost were not inventory items but PETS whom I loved dearly. I am angry about this fact mainly. That my breeding business went belly up is not as big an issue, but before this, I would have produced about 250 babies in 2000. I produced 25. Just the monetary loss to me was INCREDIBLE. But this is nothing in comparison to the price I paid having to watch my little gecko family die.
I have enclosed a list of all of the geckos that I lost due to the two infected geckos that we bought from PetCo (I kept good records). All were healthy, established, breeding adults. Please read the list and remember that I had to watch each of them die horribly:
Smootches
Binky
Boo
Stumblina
Cuddles
Eve 6
Hope
Shorty
Precious
Twerp
Tabby
Antony
Cleopatra
Sheeba
Mr Biggles
Tank
Itchy
Scratchy
Zipper
Grumpy
Lacy
Monster Man
Peanut Butter
Jelly
Thank you for your time and concern,
Thomas W. Morris
Loving Home Reptiles,
Portland, OR.
-------------------------------------------------------------------
__________________________________________________ _______________
Get your FREE download of MSN Explorer at
http://explorer.msn.com
< PTSIZE="10">
----------------------- Headers --------------------------------
Return-Path: <trace@gexfiles.com>
Received: from rly-xb01.mx.aol.com (rly-xb01.mail.aol.com [172.20.105.102]) by air-xb04.mail.aol.com (v77_r1.36) with ESMTP; Wed, 28 Mar 2001 09:21:12 -0500
Received: from yoss.nonline.net (yoss.nonline.net [207.139.235.7]) by rly-xb01.mx.aol.com (v77_r1.36) with ESMTP; Wed, 28 Mar 2001 09:20:32 -0500
Received: (from uucp@localhost)
by yoss.nonline.net (8.9.3/8.9.3) id JAA11275
for <LizardLady2001@aol.com>; Wed, 28 Mar 2001 09:20:30 -0500 (EST)
Message-Id: <200103281420.JAA11275@yoss.nonline.net>
Received: from 69.138.worldwithoutwire.com(207.139.69.138), claiming to be "[192.168.1.21]"
via SMTP by yoss.nonline.net, id smtpdJ11268; Wed Mar 28 09:20:28 2001
X-Mailer: Microsoft Outlook Express Macintosh Edition - 4.5 (0410)
Date: Wed, 28 Mar 2001 09:21:17 -0800
Subject: PetCo letter from Tom Morris
From: "Tracy Willis" <trace@gexfiles.com>
To:
LizardLady2001@aol.com
Mime-version: 1.0
X-Priority: 3
Content-type: multipart/alternative;
boundary="MS_Mac_OE_3068616077_38854_MIME_Part"
__________________________________________________ _
I had still not heard from Petco, and Trace forwarded me a copy of the correspondence she had sent and received from Kim Sherman at PetCorp.
Subj: Petco Geckos
Date: 4/6/01 1:46:01 PM Pacific Daylight Time
From:
KimSh@PETCO.com (Kim Sherman)
To:
trace@gexfiles.com ('Tracy Willis'),
KimSh@PETCO.com (Kim Sherman)
CC:
ss_leos@hotmail.com (S & S Leopard Geckos),
LizardLady2001@aol.com,
vanyul@hotmail.com (Thomas Morris)
Tracy,
I'd like to reply to the quote you included from me. I said I would have the issues addressed. I do not address them personally. Our Companion Animal Coordinators (CAC) do that.
I have been in touch with Mr. Morris. He did not have a phone number where he could be reached. I gave him the phone number of the CAC. I received a voicemail today from the CAC saying that he has not heard from Mr. Morris. I replied, asking him to begin the conversation by sending Mr. Morris an email.
I left a message for the Regional Administrative Assistant in Marcia McGuiness' area yesterday, and have forwarded him her emails. I sent him an email today asking him to check on the status of her case.
In the Utah case (email address
JcPsYKoSurie@aol.com <mailto:JcPsYKoSurie@aol.com> ), the CAC had the returned geckos tested for Cryptosporidium. The geckos did not have any Crypto, and they are in good health.
One of the other cases you sent was from early 2000, too old for investigation.
I have faithfully pursued every case you have sent to me. It takes time for such complex issues to be resolved. I ask for your patience.
Kim Sherman
PETCO Animal Supplies, Inc.
-----Original Message-----
From: Tracy Willis [mailto:trace@gexfiles.com]
Sent: Friday, April 06, 2001 10:44 AM
To: Kim Sherman
Cc: S & S Leopard Geckos;
LizardLady2001@aol.com; Thomas Morris
Subject: <no subject>
Hello Kim,
I must express my grand disappointment in the whole critical issues that we have TRIED to address to you.
You and your company seems to show "initial" concern, but frankly, words mean nothing, and you should know this. You SAY you are going to follow up, you SAY you are going to investigate and send people out, but people don't get replies, people continue to have broken hearts and this leaves a really bad taste in all of our mouths. And, worst of all, deplorable conditions continue, leopard geckos and other reptiles die by the dozen. You have not replied even to Seth and Sandi and you told me two days ago you were contact them right away (quote from your email):
"Thank you, Tracy. I am having Mr. Stevens' issues addressed immediately."
How can your company continue without a conscience? These lives are in your hands! Most have a normal life span longer than dogs and cats and they do not even live to 6 months of age!!! What about Mr. Morris and his devastating loss (financial and emotional)? Do you even know how something like that feels?
We are not giving up on this, Kim. We are going to take more action and you will know what we are up to. We have proof, we also have more and more people contacting us every single day, more and more stores are being reported. I will go directly to the supplier with the CLEAN leopard geckos and tell them what is going on as well.
Tracy Willis
PS: This letter has been also posted on kingsnake.
< PTSIZE="10">
----------------------- Headers --------------------------------
Return-Path: <KimSh@PETCO.com>
Received: from rly-yc04.mx.aol.com (rly-yc04.mail.aol.com [172.18.149.36]) by air-yc05.mail.aol.com (v77_r1.36) with ESMTP; Fri, 06 Apr 2001 16:46:00 1900
Received: from hawk.petco.com (hawk.petco.com [207.247.55.2]) by rly-yc04.mx.aol.com (v77_r1.36) with ESMTP; Fri, 06 Apr 2001 16:45:26 -0400
Received: by hawk.petc.com with Internet Mail Service (5.5.2653.19)
id <G9VQAAAA>; Fri, 6 Apr 2001 13:53:26 -0700
Message-ID: <7D5EEAF171E2D411873B0008C78614605CAEFD@harrier.pe tc.com>
From: Kim Sherman <KimSh@PETCO.com>
To: "'Tracy Willis'" <trace@gexfiles.com>, Kim Sherman <KimSh@PETCO.com>
Cc: S & S Leopard Geckos <ss_leos@hotmail.com>,
LizardLady2001@aol.com,
Thomas Morris <vanyul@hotmail.com>
Subject: Petco Geckos
Date: Fri, 6 Apr 2001 13:43:25 -0700
Importance: high
X-Priority: 1
MIME-Version: 1.0
X-Mailer: Internet Mail Service (5.5.2653.19)
Content-Type: text/plain;
charset="iso-8859-1"
__________________________________________________ __
Finally, after a few weeks I was contacted by Darren Bedel, Regional Companion Animal Coordinator for Petco. He seemed extremely concerned over this issue, and assured me it would be looked in to and dealt with accordingly. He had copies of both of my letters to Ms. Sherman, and when I asked him who the supplier of their Leopard Geckos was, he advised me that it was Bill Brandt from Gourmet Rodent. We discussed the possibility of me going in to the store for training of the employees, and he thought that was a wonderful idea and said he would contact the district manager to coordinate it with me. I wrote this letter to Ms. Sherman:
Subj: Update
Date: 4/12/01
To:
kimsh@petco.com
Dear Kim,
Thank you for your help and support. I finally got a call from Darren Bedel from the Northern California/Nevada region, and we'll see what happens... in the meantime, take a look at this:
http://herpwantads.com/forums/Inquiry/posts/2247.html
It will give you just a tiny example of how folks perceive Petco.
Sincerely,
Marcia McGuiness
"The Lizard Lady"
LizardLady2001@aol.com
__________________________________________________ __
On 4/13/01 I received a voice mail message from Kim Sherman at Petco stating that she had just spoken to Darren Bedel, and was happy that we had gotten the ‘ball rolling’ to improve the conditions at the store. I sent her this email correspondence:
Subj: Re: Update
Date: 4/13/01
To:
KimSh@PETCO.com
CC:
trace@gexfiles.com
Kim,
Thank you for your response.... I am somewhat relieved to know that there ARE those of you at Petco who truly seem to care about what's happening in your stores. I am very serious about getting this horrible situation remedied at the **** store, and I can't think of a time when I was so committed to help make a difference in the way these animals are cared for.
In contrast, I visited the store in ****, CA the other day and the reptile tanks were very clean and well maintained. The animals seemed healthy, and were all appropriately separated by species and size. The young fellow who tends the reptiles and their habitats was fairly knowledgeable and took sincere pride in his job. There were care sheets printed and in plain view for most of the reptiles that were available. This was a tremendous contrast to what I observed in the **** store, and I feel that they are an example of what any retail establishment that sells reptiles should be.
Thanks again,
Marcia McGuiness
"The Lizard Lady"
__________________________________________________ __
Subj: RE: Update
Date: 4/13/01 8:38:49 AM Pacific Daylight Time
From:
KimSh@PETCO.com (Kim Sherman)
To:
LizardLady2001@aol.com ('LizardLady2001@aol.com')
Marcia,
Thank you for the update. I'm glad you and Darren are in touch. I will check out the link, and share it with our reptile buyers and companion animal care decision makers.
Kim
PETCO Animal Supplies, Inc. __________________________________________________ __
On Easter Sunday, April 15, 2001 I received a phone call from Angela Giordano, the District Manager for the local Petco stores. She had been contacted by Darren Bedel to arrange for me to do training seminar(s) in their stores. We had a very lengthy discussion in regard to my personal experiences with the **** store, and she had copies of all the correspondence between Ms. Sherman and myself. We set the date of Wednesday, April 25 for the training.
During that time, I was very active in the Leopard Geckos Forum on Kingsnake as well as the BOI. I had posted a few times regarding Petco, and the responses I received from across the country were overwhelming. It appeared that what I had experienced in my local store was occurring in stores all over the USA. I had posted that I would be doing training locally, and was very clear that in order for Petco to remedy these issues, we needed to be very pragmatic and and provide FACTS to Kim Sherman. Here is an example of the email responses I sent to these various people:
Subj: Re: Petstore
Date: 4/22/01
To:
kbroy@conknet.com
K***,
Wow! I'm really impressed with your commitment to helping improve the conditions at the "chain-stores." I am not a "banner-waving, horn-tooting" activist on anything in my life until I was actually traumatized when I experienced the inhumane and deplorable situation at Petco.
Getting this resolved will be a long and complicated procedure, and it requires alot of diplomacy and patience... letter writing is the first step. It is critically important to be factual and credible when dealing with "corporate" mentality. (I should know, because I've been a corporate manager!) When you contact Ms. Sherman, the necessary information must include: dates, locations, names of persons dealt with, exactly what you saw or experienced, what the outcome was, and how it affected you. Factual details are the only thing that will get attention, and by offering to help rather than just complaining and/or threatening will get results.
I am very excited about the upcoming training, and hope that it will help set precedence as a small step in improving a very important problem in Petco stores.
Best Regards,
Marcia McGuiness
"The Lizard Lady"
__________________________________________________ _______________________________________
TO BE CONTINUED......