I think it's a great idea!
In regards to people paying their customers to post Good Guy posts, Who cares. If they earned it, They deserve it. How can you tell (when the Paid Membership is in place) if I pay for someone's membership to post in my favor? Ya can't, So this idea can only have minimal negative effects, if any at all, because they'll already be present.
After that, they'd still have a membership and can post experiences with other people they do business with. And to be honest, You couldn't pay me 50$ to post a good guy post if I feel that I've been taken advantage of, or a persons business ethics leave something to be desired.
I think that the sales pitch is, they get the membership, not that the experience will be a pleasurable one. The seller has to earn that assessment from the buyer. The intention shouldn't be to hand out memberships after the fact (if the deal went good), and not give them out if it goes bad. That would be wrong, one-sided and definitely wouldn't benefit the BOI. People that stack the cards in their favor will eventually be exposed for their dishonesty anyway.
I would definitely support this is if went into effect. I think we're on the same page Sasheena on this one.
As far as increasing the membership of Fauna, I can only see it as good. Because
1. It still generates revenue for this site.
2. The accountability standards will increase.
3. You're bringing new people to the table and with new people comes new Ideas.
4. Last but most important, this site will still be here to serve our community.
There will always be bad seeds, but those seeds are going to be just a little more expensive now.
Here's my Vote
Paul B.