It's a Sceloporus for sure, but without history species identification will be extremely difficult. You will have to use biological measurements (perhaps even including scale counts) to identify to species. I'm leaning towards eastern fence lizard (Sceloporus undulatus), which is actually native to Virginia and this individual could simply be wild caught. I do not recommend releasing this individual even if native, however, due to the potential of spreading parasites or diseases to novel areas. I would also check state laws in case sale or possession of native herpetofauna are prohibited. Photos of the full dorsal, belly, throat, and armpit in much better light (and image resized to not be gigantic) would aid in identification.