I put in a claim with my bank about a week ago, but had to wait since it hadn't been a full 15 days since I originally placed the order. I put my phone through the washer a couple days later and didn't have a phone to contact my bank about it when enough time had passed, but I called them today, they put the $61.16 in my account and are doing an investigation. I'm not even going to touch the money until the investigation is closed, just in case.
I am just...insanely frustrated. I've always been careful about who I buy from, but I got lazy on looking into them and this is what I get. I am going to be extra careful from now on.