Check the BOI before buying. Sounds silly to have to mention it but there is one of the best pieces of advice you can follow.
Also ask for references. Then contact the references via snail mail or email and ask them to snail mail you a reference for the seller. The best way to do this is to send the reference person a self addressed and stamped envelope (why should they be spending money for stamps for you). This way you can be assured that the references are not the seller using multiple screen names to email you great references he made up for himself. It is amazing how many people will not check references, but you can probably be pretty sure that a seller is not mailing you letters of reference from 5 or 6 different states. If they all come from Paduka, Illinois and the seller is located in Babishka, Illinois (the next town over) you can bet it is a scam.
Make sure you know exactly what you are getting before you pay. Get an exact description of the animal, the shipping method, and any guarantee. Also get a picture of the animal if possible. While a picture is nice it is not mandatory. Not everyone has a camera, for example I don't, but I still sell quality snakes and other items over the net. Sometimes I can borrow a camera and sometimes not. I sure don't want to buy one just to sell a few surplus snakes each year so I give an excellent description of what I am selling. I guarantee satisfaction within two days of delivery but you would have to follow my rules to get the purchase price refunded (not hard to follow, but you would have to follow them exactly as I don't want to get screwed either). I also guarantee live delivery. Beyond that I do not guarantee anything else. Be careful of what you are getting, read all of the print.
To be safest of all use a herp site for which sellers have to pay a listing fee (sorry faunaclassifieds). Sites like faunaclassifieds are great but scammers are probably more likely to use one like this because they do not have to lay out any cash before using the site. They then also do not have to supply a credit card number or other identifying data about themselves to the service. Using a site like kingsnake.com is probably safer because sellers had to pay for the use of the service, thereby making it more likely that the seller is legitimate because most low level scammers (in my opinion) are looking to make money without spending money. I am not saying not to use faunaclassifieds.com, I use it often. But if you do, then make use of the BOI and check out the seller. I would like to see these sites (both faunaclassifieds and kingsnake) use a feedback feature like other sites such as AuctionArms.com or Ebay.com. This is a good feature and in addition to the BOI would be almost an assurance that you knew the reputation of with whom you are dealing.
Pay by CREDIT CARD as this offers the maximum protection against fraud. If they do not accept plastic, then use: PayPal or another online money transfer service or use a U.S. Postal Money order. If someone defrauds you when you used a postal money order, it is now a federal offense.
Use an escrow service such as that offered by PayPal. You pay through PayPal but the money goes into an escrow account where it is held until you say you were satisfied with the merchandise.
Did I say check the BOI, sure I did! <img src="http://www.faunaclassifieds.com/iB_html/non-cgi/emoticons/smile.gif" border="0" valign="absmiddle" alt='

'> <img src="http://www.faunaclassifieds.com/iB_html/non-cgi/emoticons/tounge.gif" border="0" valign="absmiddle" alt='

'> <img src="http://www.faunaclassifieds.com/iB_html/non-cgi/emoticons/smile.gif" border="0" valign="absmiddle" alt='

'>