Unlike a domestic cat or dog, Cb reptiles and amphibians do very well in the wild. Because they never truly domesticate, nor do they depend on us. Only to put food in the tank or cage they reside in. Their hunter instinct, never goes away. When you drop a food item into a cage for a reptile, they instantly go into their instinctive "Hunting Mode", as if they were in the wild and this item had naturally just crossed their path. If it weren't for the rules within specific states in regards to disease transference everyone would be able to simply release the animals they keep, so long as they are domestic species to begin with. All of my life I've been catching, raising, and releasing local species. Turtles, snakes, and whatever else interested me. Starting with either wild caught, or C.b. Snapping turtles, Box Turtles, Wood Turtles, and even Bog Turtles when I lived in the small patch of area in the states they inhabit. I suppose it depends on how you look at something. I look at what I do, as helping populations thrive.. When a baby turtle is born, they are in great danger of being eaten, by anything from a bird, to a fish, to even a BullFrog... If I happen to catch a Hatchling, I generally keep it 'til it's got about a 4" Carapace, and then release it back almost where I found it. At 4", aside from man, not much would bother to harass a typical turtle.
Though I do understand the laws of nature, "Only the strong survive" and all of that, which is fine out in wooded areas where there is no human population to start with. However, In the summer time, many times I drive down a road I see something that got squashed by a car. This doesn't apply in the rules of nature and isn't ever even considered in most surveys. Therefore, If I can repopulate areas 1 for 1, with the ratio for turtles being run over by cars, I feel like I'm just helping keep whatever the current population already is, in balance. So, marking what is probably my 30th year keeping local species and raising them to, or beyond the 4" Carapace, or in a case of the snakes, 3' if I can, I will continue to do this indefinitely.
Each one I release, is the replacement for something killed by man. Being that I don't keep and release them in very high numbers, and generally only a couple of or a few at a time, I can't imagine that I could be off-setting any kind of natural balance in the first place. If I am though, than it's in a positive way, not a negative one.
I live in New England. This past summer I caught 5 baby, and 6 fully grown adult Red Eared Sliders in local ponds... This is a problem, because they can adapt, and are an invasive species. This is something I do not condone to, and never will. But I hate being lectured by a friend I grew up with, whom works for the E.P.A. about how bad it is, when I feed a local Salamander, or frog, once in a while, to my locally caught snake or Turtle.
If you guys want to do the same thing I do with gators, go right ahead.. Just don't drop them in the sewers of New York City, and don't do it in high numbers and you release healthy ones into the wild who've been socialized with others of their kind if possible.... I know I'm going to get some arguments here about this, and it's not my intention. However, a few here or there doesn't seem like a big deal to help even some odds on mother natures behalf..