I think you have a good point.If posts could be kept simple, on topic, and without all the name calling and petty back and forth nonsense the post in its entirety would be far more useful to people just looking for experiences from other buyers/sellers.
A few posts ago I asked about the agreement not to post vet reports, it was met with zero answers. It may be that one or more of the parties has something to hide.
There is a lot not being said in this thread and not only by one party, prospective buyers/sellers should take note of what is not being said, not being posted, and relevant, critical information that is being deliberately withheld and ask themselves why that might be.
What was the logic behind this agreement you say the two of you had?
Perhaps the birth of a collaborative relationship could be initiated by talking about the expectations of each party, why former choices were made, and how future choices can strengthen reputations and relationships.