Here goes, he emailed me back in July and said he was interested and wanted the snakes shipped to upstate NY. We began talking about everything and on the second or third day after initial contact he sent me the money to hold them and was going to pay them off over a short period of time. I can't remember exactly how long. I told him to consider them sold and took down the ads.
Ryan,
Is there somewhere in writing that states his down payment is a non-refundable deposit? No one wants to throw $500 in the air, just put yourself in his shoes. You spent the money before delivering the animals and then you traded the animals for something else. How do you expect anyone to answer to that?
Then a day or 2 after sending the money he mentions being in Canada and I was confused. After realizing he was in Canada, right over the border, we got into the whole issue of customs and problem with shipping over the border...many different subjects. He was more concerned than I was. I said I could try shipping them and we'll see what happens but he was actually the one who didn't want to chance it. He tried contacting FedEx locations in NY to see if they could hold the package there and he could make the drive to pick it up, things like that. This was 4 months ago. I don't remember everything like it just happened.
It’s understandable that after 4 months you don’t remember (I wouldn’t after two!). That’s why is
so important to take a look at the e-mail exchange and/or have him post his version of the deal.
Anyway, he was more the one saying that it wasn't a good idea to transcend borders in case something happened. I just brought it to his attention and said that if I had known he was actually in Canada, I would have backed out of the deal immediately. He understood that since I had already sent the money somewhere else and it was his mistake that I couldn't return the money right away, although I would have if I could. I said that if I could find a buyer for them, I would send it back to him.
Here is where the problem is. You had the snakes and you offered to sell them to pay him back. That shows good business practices and goodwill on your side. He might have taken your word for it and was waiting for you to sell them and send him back his money.
I contacted him twice between July and October asking if he had come up with anything and still wanted them, etc. The last email I remeber from him said he would ask a friend if they might want them and could figure something out that way. I never heard back from him after that and had really pretty much forgotten about it.
Here’s the other problem. You received the payment, kept the snakes, and forgot about it? There was a $500 down payment on the snakes, which you offered to sell to return his money!
I figured it was pretty much understood that he made a mistake. He wasn't pushy about anything at all.
You figured that because he wasn’t pushy he was dropping the issue and forgetting you owed him either $500 or the snakes?
Over 3 months, I didn't find another buyer and finally traded them.
Sorry, but in MHO this was a big no-no. You were not supposed to get rid of the snakes until everything was squared away with him.
Then he emails out of nowhere saying that he hasn't seen any ads for them lately and wants his money now. It just seems like he wants something all of a sudden and thinks he can come collect from me.
He wants what he paid for or his money back. Is that unreasonable? For all we know he could’ve had problems in getting in touch with you, that’s why is so important to hear his side of the story.
Did you notify him of this thread He can contact Rich to post for free.
I had pretty much forgotten about it and thought we had already reached an understanding.
You thought you both had reached and understanding, but what was he thinking. Was the understanding that you get to keep the money and the snakes?
I personally don't feel I owe him anything. Just wanted to see how other people would handle the situation.
It seems you had made up your mind before posting in here. Unless we hear from him corroborating everything, acknowledging his mistake, and releasing you from any responsibility my opinion is that you either owe him the money or the snakes. The snakes are gone.
Again, as you say this is just how I would handle the situation and by no means I’m suggesting is the way it should be done. But, you asked for input, and there were my 2 cents…
Regards