First of all, thank you for your extremely mature and insightful negative karma comment... truly, a stunning example of Internet machismo. I especially appreciated how you figured that my incredulity at actually litigating this situation was due to my being unable to afford a lawyer... or "coins" on FC, as if that has anything to do with anything. Not sure why the guy with the 800 square foot house that's only worth twice the amount we just spent on a basement renovation is lecturing me on what I can and can't afford, but suit yourself.
The fact is, there is nothing to be gained from filing a small claim on this, as anyone who's ever ever researched ANYTHING about filing a small claim already knows. Small claims are not CRIMINAL matters, they are CIVIL, and are not the "auto-win" cash generators that people think they are. First of all, you have to file the lawsuit in small claims court (plus fees), you have to hire a private process server to serve the defendant with the lawsuit (plus fees), you have to appear in court or have a lawyer do it for you (very $$ if you hire representation, and is NOT automatically granted a "+court costs" restitution if a judgment is won... and no lawyer in their right mind is going to take a small claims case on contingency), you have to argue your case with evidence, and you are then PERSONALLY responsible for collecting the money from the defendant, EVEN IF YOU WIN. Everyone always thinks that winning a small claims case means that the defendant gets thrown in jail unless they pay or something, but it's literally a judgment that confirm that the defendant owes the plaintiff the money the plaintiff claims is due, the courts do NOT get involved in helping you collect. In order to collect that debt, you either have to hire a professional collection agency (for a fee/%) or go through all the legwork for taking your proof of judgment to the Sheriff's office and having them issue a legal writ of garnishment or whatever may be appropriate for the situation.
For a situation where no actual fraud occurred, no money changed hands, and for the amount of $200 in money that was never actually spent? Yes, you have to be kidding.