No, I disagree entirely. When someone finds that many animals in such disgusting conditions, I see no reason the person not providing proper care should get all of their animals back. Compare this to a man who has a dog that got hit by a car but he does not want to provide medical care. The animal control agency will be called and they will treat the dog. After this, the man will probably not receive the animal back. The only difference here is that this was even more neglectful and on a much larger scale. These guys honestly deserved to have their animals confiscated and do not deserve a second chance.
You are comparing apples to oranges. A family dog is a part of the family and should be treated as such, there is love an affection between the dog and owners family. Animals that were brought in from another country for resale are not beloved pets, they are inventory, there is no loving affection between inventory and a human being. Animals that come in from some of the third world countries are often times in bad shape before they get here. I would guess that you have never been in an importers facility before. It isn't profitable to spend a lot of money on vet care for cheap animals. Iguanas, for example, they cost roughly $1.00 each for the importer. Why would an importer spend $50.00 on an iguana vet bill when they sell them for $2.50? Again, I do not like to see animals die, but from a business point of view you have to draw the line somewhere. Excessive vet bills would put all importers out of business. A business is in business to make money.
The survival rate of imported animals as a whole is much greater then the survival rate of animals in the wild.
People want cheap, that is just the way it is. Without importation of some of the species that are brought in, the cost would go way up, hurting pet stores as well as the consumer. A lot of animals that are brought in are not bred in captivity here in the states, or if they are they are bred by hobbiest that do it for fun because they lose money after all of the expenses are added up for the care of their breeders.
It's weird what some people call inhumane. A lizard that costs $1.00 dies and you are up in arms, but you can go to your local department store and buy clothes that came from a third world country, where children are like slave labor, who work 12 hours a day or more for what we call pocket change. So you can buy clothes made by people living and working in filth, and being exploited so you can have cheap clothes, but that is alright.
Instead of focusing on a $1.00 iguana, how about trying to help the people that are considered slave labor? Or is it because people can justify buying cheap clothes for themselves and their families, after all you buy a lot more clothes in your life time then you buy animals.
Again, people want cheap. If those same clothes were made in the states, a shirt that now costs $5.00 would cost $20.00. It's amazing at what people are willing to turn their back on and what they won't. Hey, whatever suits your needs, right?
What would happen to retail stores if they couldn't buy these cheap clothes?
What would happen to the consumer if they had to spend a considerable amout more for their clothing?
It's the same with animals. I have never heard anyone say that the importation of animals was pretty.
Global should have every right to those animals.
If you were not there then you really don't know the truth, so people should not be so quick to judge.
I am not defending Global here, maybe they were at fault in some cases, I don't know, I wasn't there. But all people make mistakes, some bigger then others. Regardless of what the case may be, they should have gotten their animals back and given another chance.
When people ask, where did the animals go and the responce is, to an undisclosed location. There are reasons for that. One of them is because they more then likely aren't getting propper care there either. No rescue group is capible of taking in the amount of animals that were confiscated, therefore, if you don't know where they are, you cannot see the conditions they are in by there so called rescuers.
Brian Dierking