Sorry I had to be away for the entire day, but some of us do have jobs to go to that require our time. I have attempted to read all of the posts made throughout the day. pch101, I knew that no matter what came out you would take her side, possibly because I have never posted on any forum before and no one knows me, but talk about dissecting every item. Yes, there has been an explanation provided for everything that happened along the way, and all of it is logical, but again I ask, how many people would wait through seemingly unending problems and leave themselves unprotected? I believe Terese's perception comes closest to what was going through my mind- since pch101 want to dissect thing, let's do that.
1. What is not in dispute- I DID pay in full for the transaction entered into.
True, but you also filed your complaint NINE DAYS after sending the funds, not leaving me time to really do anything.
2. Why were the snakes not shipped before she left?
Possible explanation - not enough time. Accepted.
You paid for the snakes on FRIDAY JULY 8th. I left for the hurricane evacuation on the morning of SATURDAY JULY 9th. Everyone here knows that you can't ship reptiles on a Friday, it even says that in my live reptile shipping contact with FedEx. And FYI, I did send you an e-mail telling you I was leaving becuase of the hurricane evacuation, so you were aware that I was leaving immediately after that e-mail was sent, as I had stated in the e-mail.
3. Why were the snakes not shipped after she evacuated to the new location.
That was the question that I never got an answer to.
Possible explanation- too inconvenient from away from home. Accepted
Then things start to get suspicious
How exactly is it that I can ship from a hotel room in the middle of Nowhere, Mississippi? It was all I could do to pack up abotu 50 reptiles into rubbermaid containers and get my other animals into carriers and throw some clothes in a suitcase before I had to leave, besides this fact, this was over a WEEKEND and during a MANDATORY hurricane evacuation. You don't actually think that FedEx AND the airports stayed OPEN even as for North as I was do you? I am sure you can call and verify that they were definitely NOT OPEN FOR BUSINESS during a hurricane situation.
4. I am informed that some of the snakes I paid for had died.
Possible explanation- Her car broke down 90 miles from home.
Now I start to question- she told me she was evacuating to her mother's apartment. If she was 110 mile from home at her mother's apartment and 90 miles from home when she broke down, doesn't that mean she was only 20 miles from family? Why would it take a full day for assistance and cause the loss of life of so many animals?
(Please note: I am not proposing anything here, just posting out loud the thought process I was going through.)
As I stated in my original reply her on the BOI: My initial plan was to go to my mother’s apartment (since Damien was out of town with his mother) but my mother’s apartment building was evacuated too and she had to leave as well. She decided to head for her sister’s house in Texas and I decided to just “drive North” as the people on the TV were advising us to do. So I left this area with a car full of animals. My mother was about 400 miles or so away and Damien was even much further than that, but you already know that becuase this is now the THIRD TIME I have explained that to you.
5. I then receive notice that ALL the ball pythons died.
Starting to question again.
As I told you NOW for the FOUTH TIME, not all the snakes died at one time. I lost about half of all of them before I got home. Several others died within a couple days of when I got home. AND as I already told you, I do still have 6 of them that appear to be fine and healthy now, feeding fine and no worse for the wear.
6. I receive notice that even though I have paid in full, I cannot get a refund for an extended period of time.
Now I am seriously beginning to question if this is a rip off that someone is stalling on.
Again, I have explained this to you several times. I drained all the funds I had while evacuating for the hurricane. I also lost my job earlier in the month. I told you I would refund you on the morning fo the 29th if you wanted a refund. I also offered you replacement snakes and left it up to you to decide which option you wanted. You told me again and again that you wanted the snakes, not the money.
7. The offer of replacement animals is also contingent upon a waiting period, even though they are supposed to be available from the breeder now.
Thought process- if she really has a long time working relationship with this breeder, and she was as trustworthy as she says, wouldn't he drop ship FOR her and bill her?
Thought process continues- this is import season, perhaps she made up the story of her animals dying and sold them for a higher price and is stalling to take a shipment of imports to replace them with.
I also explained this to you as well. I don't just take any snakes someone sends me, I liek to hand pick snakes for one. For another thing, you were aware that my wholesaler and I were making a TRADE in which I had to DELIVER certain items WHEN I picked up the snakes. I had to have told you that at least three times now. If I wanted to "take a shipment of imports to replace them with" as you accuse me of, I could have placed an order with any number of people and had them in 24 hours. That just doesn't make any sense!
8. So at this point, without "jumping the gun" or "making unreasonable demands" I ask if there is a contact number number for the breeder to verify that the replacement she is proposing are from him. (if she had this long standing wholesaler/retailer relationship with him, he would not violate it either)
This was NOT a part of our original or any subsequent deals. This was something you demanded after we had worked things out (or so I thought). And when I refused to give out CONFIDECTAIL information, you IMMEDIATELY filed a complaint with PayPal, within HOURS.
9. The response I get states she will be away from her computer and unable to respond.
Thought process- this was not an unsolicited response "just in case I tried to get in touch with her", it was in direct response to a posed question to provide a verification that the NEW REPLACEMENTS were the same category of animals THE ORIGINAL ORDER was for.
Thought process continued- If she had simply not wanted to provide the number for her wholesale source wouldn't she say "I don't want to give out the number for may wholesale source" instead of "I will be away from my computer"
Nervousness is really beginning to set in.
I TOLD YOU I WOULD BE AWAY FROM MY COMPUTER FOR 24 HOURS!!!!! How many times do I have to repeat "away for 24 hours" before it sinks into your head...? Why was it such a BIG DEAL for me to be away from my computer for 24 hours???
10. At that point I explain that it is sounding like a scam and request a refund filing a complaint with PayPal..
You filed a PayPal complaint within just a couple HOURS of when I told you I wasn't giving out the name and number of the person I purchase from, since that is confidential as far as I am concerned. You filed a PayPal complait out of SPITE and you know you did it, that is very clear to me now. You even LISTED THE REASON FOR YOUR COMPLAINT WITH PAYPAL AS: becuase I wouldn't give you confiential info. I already copied and pasted that earleir today.
11. She THEN provides the explanation that she doesn't want to give up her wholesale source.
See above answer to #10
12. I accept that explanation, but tell her as politely as possible that due to the numerous setbacks and inconsistencies I cannot in good judgement leave myself unprotected by canceling the complaint prior to receiving the animals.
Thought process- remember, when faced with a complaint through paypal she had the resolution choices of issue a refund or provide proof of shipment. She chose to mail a receipt and provide a USPS tracking number leading them to believe the ordered items had been shipped- another item that does little to gain my confidence and causes more concern that this has become very shady.
Maybe you didn't see my first post here. Here is an excerpt from it regarding this: 7/20/05 I sent the buyer an e-mail stating that I had mailed out a Merchandise Credit Certificate good for 20 female ball pythons and reflecting the $450.00 he had paid for the,. The Credit Certificate stated that his snakes could be sent on or after August 1, 2005. I figured this might help him put his mind at ease, having something in writing from me. I submitted to PayPal that I had sent him this Credit Certificate, I even sent them a copy of it showing that I understood he was entitled to the 20 female ball pythons. (Note: I didn’t hear directly back from the Buyer again until 7/25/05 when he asked me a laundry list of questions and I answered each one.) "
13. Research through PayPal reveals that a refund will only be made if there are funds in the seller's account to cover such a refund.
Thought process- she may be tempting me away from the complain to empty her account and simply never respond again. If I do that I will have no recourse left.
WHY did you file a PayPal complaint anyway, after ONLY 9 DAYS?!?! You had given me very, very little time to do ANYTHING in "jumping the gun" and filing your complaint. You had 45 DAYS after you paid to file a complaint, yet your chose to HURRY and do it really quickly.
14. Aprylla then insists that she will not make shipment until AFTER the complaint has been cancelled.
This simply reinforces the last thought that she is trying to empty her account and leave me helpless. After all, I had sent payment in full in the first place. I had demonstrated SOME sort of trust by doing that. Now I was faced with someone who is treating ME as an untrustworthy individual and making demands on ME Before she would make ANY move to live up to her end of a deal that had already been made.
15. I informed her of my concern and assured her the complain would be canceled immediately upon receipt of the animals, and even offered to do continued business afterward as long as thing went as promised.
16. Her response was to not make shipment OR refund unless ordered through PayPal.
Thought process- if this was unacceptable to her, and there was over $600.00 in her PayPal account she could just hit the "Issue refund" button in the resolution center. Once resolved, her account would be free to send and receive money again and she would be free to do business as usual.
17. Her response was not to use the resolution center for a refund, but to send an e-mail to PayPal authorizing such (Which, by the way, I have never had independent confirmation from PayPal, only her and Damien's e-mail saying that they did it. And I have accepted it as the truth.)
So..................
While there may well be an explanation for EVERYTHING that EVER goes wrong in life, how many in a series of misfortunes are we expected to simply dismiss before we become suspicious. And then, from a total stranger that has offered this series of misfortunes as their explanation to DEMAND from me that I back down BEFORE they fulfil ANY PART of their end of the deal I feel is unreasonable.
By the way, I DID watch CNN, AND THE WEATHER CHANNEL, which both reported that the storm did VERY LITTLE damage and were MUCH LESS than expected. Not that she would have known that ahead of time- Just one more little tidbit with all the other series of events that placed doubt in my mind.
Well gee, I am so sorry that the hurricane didn't destroy the entire city I live in! Maybe if it had you'd have waited a whole 10 DAYS to file your PayPal complaint. I will have to guess that you MUST have lived up North your whole life and NEVER lived in a hurricane prone area...? Let me tell you something mister, when the National Weather Service says "there is a Catagoty 4 Hurricane that is likely to make landfall (dircetly on the city you live in) you DO NOT ASK QUESTIONS, you pack your collective "stuff" in a hurry...or you can stay and possibly kiss your rear end goodbye if it actually DOES hit you. Hurricanes are not something you want to mess with and think "oh it won;t be so bad" you HAVE to assume that the worst might happen and prepare for it as best you can. It was a BLESSING to myself and thousands of other people in MS, AL, and FL that Hurricane Dennis weakend and only caused abotu $3 -$5 MILLION in damage (and by the way, I don't call $3-$5 MILLION worth of dmaage "very little"). I saw the picturres of the area that were hit, and although it wasn't as bad as it could have been, there were a lot of homes and property destroyed or severly damaged where the hurricane made landfall. That area could JUST HAVE EASILY been my city that was badly damaged (there but for the grace of God go I, you know that saying).
Now, do you still think that I was UNREASONABLE to simply ask for the animals to be shipped before I canceled the complaint?
????? I don't even know what to say to that. After looking for your name everywhere to find any sort of good or bad feedback I have come up with nothing. I no longer trust you at this point. I have to say that at least a very *small* person in the reptile world, at leats I have a few peopel I have doen business with in the past willing to say they had good deals with me. I can find zero about you even though you told me you have been breeding ball pythons for a while. At this point I don't know that you are not trying to scam ME and take the money AND the ball ptyhons.
I too have been set by accidents and misfortune in the past, I just didn't think it would be reasonable to make someone else pay for my misfortune. I think I would have said, "I know that this whole series of events sound fishy. Since you paid in full, I will make the shipment as agreed, but expect to have the complain canceled immediately upon receipt." (Which I had already promised to do) Remember, no show of faith had EVER been made on her part, only on mine by sending payment in full in the first place.