David,
First, I appreciate you defending your friend, and your personal knowledge of the gecko, and the situation. That being said, we need to clarify a few things:
First - don't call someone a liar when there was no intention behind it. I know you don't know me, but let's be clear on something. I have NO reason to lie. I called our warehouse TODAY when I saw this post. I asked our girls what happened, and the time frame. They had EXACT dates written on his invoice. Now, that being said - it is CERTAINLY possible that they either made an error, or, they just didn't mark the first phone call down. If that is the case, as I told your friend, it is an HONEST mistake. However, the FACT is still this. The gecko did NOT show up looking infested. He told our girls this. Hell - he told the BOI this. He didn't notice an issue right away, as it was not infested upon arrival to the naked eye. We LOOK for this when we pack them - regardless if you believe it or not. Keep in mind - we all love reptiles over here too....
2nd - You are RIGHT. It is NOT ok to sell a "mite infested" animal of any sort. I did NOT say this, nor would I ever condone it. That is plain stupid. You know this. You saying this on the board like it is the norm at LLL is inflamatory, and honestly pointless. It is simply not the case. ALL I said was that wild caught Uroplatus, and other wild caught geckos commonly come in with red mites. We know this. We LOOK for it, and we treat them accordingly. I guarantee you this - I don't know you, but I have seen more Uroplatus than most anyone in the US. I am very, very familiar with the treatment of these mites. I wasn't asking if it was "ok" to treat them with reptile relief. Bottom line - there are BETTER, less stressful ways to do this, and this ABSOLUTELY will increase stress on the gecko. In that original picture of his gecko - besides the bugs, the gecko looks very, very healthy. You being an avid keeper - I am sure you can see that as well, which is probably why your friend chose to take on the issue.
On your friend's receipt - that he got WITH his animal, and on our website, it absolutely is clear. Shipping is NOT refundable, and not covered for any reason. In this case, AFTER our written guarantee, your friend called. He COULD have asked to return it had he called within the guaranteed time. He chose to treat it, and wait - regardless of the exact dates. Knowing this, I am sure that is why him and Kate were able to work out what they both thought was a FAIR credit. The only problem here is that your friend thought shipping would be free. That is what this boils down to. And now, because shipping is not free, he, and you, have chosen to speak up on the BOI. I don't need to defend us here. There are plenty here who know our business well enough to stand up for us. I choose to because I like to make every effort with every customer. Do you get that? Do you realize that is why I just wrote you this novel?
I sure hope so. I am guessing that no matter what I say here, we are not going to get anywhere, and you will remain with your opinions. But myself, and the many, many hard working people at our company will continue to do everything possible to help our customers in the future. Unfortunately, as the old saying goes, you can't please everyone. But when you agree to take an $80 dollar store credit, and then want an additional $35 dollars to cover shipping after the fact, and then take it to the BOI - there is little I can do. I will see how your friend responds, and see if there is anything further I can / will do for him then.
Good luck with your reptiles either way. Nothing here is personal against you or your friend. I would hope you both keep it on a professional level as well.