Bill & Amy
Harley Rider
Lets say you get an email back, how do you prove its not him? I can setup an yahoo or hotmail email address and send you a email signed Razz?
Chameleon Company said:I am not here to stir the pot or defend Ray, but I do feel a need to say that before I post. Considering the circumstances, I have no trouble understanding your anger at the way Ray has characterized you with his "Shame" thing, the labels, etc. I think that your actions to bring legal weight to bear on Ray (contacting all the agencies that you did), was motivated in part by his decision to post your name as he did. I think you stated such earlier. It also seems that the recent frenzy of complaints, very likely spear-headed by yours, created the situation where the need for new identities was necessary for business survival, and which led to the "outing" of these identities in this thread. If Ray's posting of your name was the straw (or stick) that broke the camel's back in bringing this final flood of bad tidings on him, then it may serve as a wonderful example of "people who live in glass houses shouldn't throw stones" ........ I love the old sayings and adages.
Again, I sympathize completely with how you have been mischaracterized. And you may still be able to cause all sorts of problems for Ray, especially if you are willing to commit money in a legal manner, and even if not prevail, cause Ray to spend money likewise. I say "not prevail", because the burden to prove that you have been libeled is very high. You know that you are not a thief. But you are in possession of a turtle for which you received a full refund. This is not about the related costs and difficulties of shipping the animal back, but for so long as you have both the refund and the turtle, the courts are likely to not slap down Ray for having his opinion that you are a thief, as again, you have the refund and the product. People need to realize that while you had medical bills, the true way to recover for them if you and Ray did not have an agreement, would be by lawsuit. If you are keeping the turtle, or the refund, to cover those costs, you have essentially arbitrarily seized an asset without a court order. Much of this is not cut-and-dry, but again, proving libel has a very high threshold.
I would ask that any who want to join the discussion and "debate" the "libel-not libel" threshold do so based on experience with attorneys and the courts on such issues. I know what I am saying, that Ray can call Kelly a "thief", sounds unfair. Kelly's situation is certainly not libel "per-se", meaning a blatant lie, as Ray has a basis for his opinion. A "per-se" case would be far easier to prove from Kelly's position.
Now, can Ray sue you for either the turtle or the money? He could, but there's not a chance in Hell he would prevail, because of the circumstances. But can he call you a thief, provide the basic details for his opinion, and stay well within the burden of proof you would need to find it libel or slander? You do not need to be a convicted thief for someone to call you one. They need only a reasonable basis. Kelly, I truly applaud your actions, and I would hope that Ray would realize that "payback is a mother .....", and take down his tit-for-tat "wall of shame". Good luck in all.
I am not saying that you should ship it back, as I do not feel that is the correct thing to do, but it need not be driven, and while not the easiest thing to do, it can be shipped........ and I COULD not return the animal unless I felt like driving down to Florida from Maryland to hand deliver it to him because of federal shipping laws regarding turtles/tortoises that have been beaten to death here already.
Gecko_Den said:Interesting how the address was exactly the same on both of these, but in a remarkable coincidence once the proof was posted all of a sudden the info has changed to:
Domain Name.......... northportreptiles.com
Creation Date........ 2006-04-03
Registration Date.... 2006-04-03
Expiry Date.......... 2007-04-03
Organisation Name.... Ramon Torres
Organisation Address. 4654 Sr 64 east #017
Organisation Address. #107
Organisation Address. Bradenton
Organisation Address. 34208
Organisation Address. FL
Organisation Address. UNITED STATES
Rebel Dragons said:One little correction........
Actually the Bradenton address is in Manatee County and the Ft Myers address is in Lee County. Bradenton and Ft Myers are about 90 miles from each other.
Domain Name.......... northportreptiles.com
Creation Date........ 2006-04-03
Registration Date.... 2006-04-03
Expiry Date.......... 2007-04-03
Organisation Name.... Ramon Torres
Organisation Address. 4654 Sr 64 east #017
Organisation Address. #107
Organisation Address. Bradenton
Organisation Address. 34208
Organisation Address. FL
Organisation Address. UNITED STATES
kstigile said:well, if you happened to know this, ray was advertising on his site and his forum that he was getting a 7,000sq ft facility to house the reptiles. he never mentioned where, but maybe thats the address for northpoint? that or he just used a friend's address. all other signs point to that organization being the same as ray's reptilia.
anyone know where ray went? suddenly he disappeared again since he was called out so drastically...lol
kelly
scalesnstuff said:Once i have received the email my email app or Dreamhost (my web host) supplies me with the name that it was registered with. If he did not use an alias then i will know, if he did then I will not. I am hoping that the person will post here, most of you are familiar with ray and could probably tell by style etc if it is him.
Domain Name.......... sunshinestatereptiles.com
Creation Date........ 2006-04-23
Registration Date.... 2006-04-23
Expiry Date.......... 2007-04-23
Organisation Name.... Florida Reptiles INC.
Organisation Address. P O Box 99800
Organisation Address.
Organisation Address. EmeryVille
Organisation Address. 94662
Organisation Address. CA
Organisation Address. US
Admin Name........... PrivateRegContact Admin
Admin Address........ P O Box 99800
Admin Address........
Admin Address........ EmeryVille
Admin Address........ 94662
Admin Address........ CA
Admin Address........ US
Admin Email.......... [email protected]
Admin Phone.......... +1.5105952002
Admin Fax............
Tech Name............ PrivateRegContact TECH
Tech Address......... P O Box 99800
Tech Address.........
Tech Address......... EmeryVille
Tech Address......... 94662
Tech Address......... CA
Tech Address......... US
Tech Email........... [email protected]
Tech Phone........... +1.5105952002
Tech Fax.............
Name Server.......... yns1.yahoo.com
Name Server.......... yns2.yahoo.com