yeah. i see there is 2 sections now...
one is strict, the other is open. go figure. theres so many dif sub forums , this site is pretty complex.
But there is a difference between the way the black and white way the traders ratings operate compared to the more free form
Board
Of
Inquiry. With the traders ratings, there is no opportunity for the member to whom the rating is being applied to respond to any negative feedback left there. Pretty much anyone can leave feedback there with no way for it to be questioned. Someone can simply leave a negative rating with a comment like "Seller sent me mite infested animals that all died", and that is that. You can't even comment about that claim.
The
Board
Of
Inquiry, however, puts everyone who posts there under the spotlight and can be cross examined by ANYONE who cares to do so. It is not at all unusual for someone posting completely bogus claims to be raked over the coals for doing so, and have their own credibility suffer because of it. Members here CAN get to the truth with the open structure of the BOI allowing free discourse to try to get to the bottom of claims made.
So with those facts in mind, it seemed prudent to more tightly restrict a feedback method that could obviously be abused quite severely without some sort of control in place.
To give you an example, someone could create 10 different registrations here and slam your traders ratings feedback with 10 negative ratings. What could you do about it? Not a thing. But I would bet you would be coming to me asking ME to do something about it. Now if that same person goes to the BOI and posts something negative, YOU can post a rebuttal, as well as ask for some sort of proof of the allegations. Others will join in, and if such proof is not forthcoming, the thread in the BOI about you will show the falseness of the claims based on the evidence that is NOT shown.
So yes, everything can be subjected to abuse, but I am trying to put in safeguards where possible to limit such abuse as much as is possible to do, under the circumstances...