Hello,
I really don't even know where to start with all of this. While I am not a breeder, I still share concerns where the future will be going with bearded dragons.
I think my main concern right now, is the fact there is discrepancies of care from the 2 sources of the silkies. We really do need to know the facts. What I fear, is once they do start to try to breed them, unless they already are, is that there could be some serious injuries.
Look at females with scales, they STILL get injuries from breeding, so, I think it is a pretty safe bet that their scaleless counterparts would get an injury as well. It just makes sense. My other fear is that while they may be offered on a limited basis, they will still be offered. Currently, there are so many people who cannot even properly take care of a conventional bearded dragon, what makes us think that a scaleless bearded dragon is going to be safe in the public's hands? Chances are, they will not be cared for properly.
I personally, do not think it is fair forcing the breeding aspect in order to bring out a "desirable" trait. The dragons don't have a choice in the matter sure. If it is something that has to be inbred into them in order to force the desirable trait out, it will weaken them in one way or another which is not desirable in today's population. Yes, they probably do inbreed a little bit in the wild, but there is a much more diverse population to choose from than what we have to offer. They do not purposely do it, as they may lack numbers of proper male to female ratios on occasion. What we are doing is purposely, so, it is looked at as unethical.
I too, simply do not trust anything from these 2 sources. I know all about Dachiu's background & history. I am NOT impressed. While I do not know much to anything about Alessandro, if he wants to inform us & keep us informed, then, he needs to stick around to defend himself during these hard discussions. He has surely already proven that he can't take the heat, so, if he doesn't want to answer, or cannot answer, he simply does what is convenient to him, he disappears.
Yes, he was gracious enough to come on & answer questions & provide background to us, etc, but why can't he stick around now? If he is that concerned, then, he needs to be around to defend himself & his project as he calls it.
Tracie