I just found out about this thread today and this is my reply to Lisa along with my resolution:
"Paypal does not get involved in disputes over live animal sales which is why you lost your dispute. I also want Elvis back if you are going to get a full refund (you could still keep him and get all your money back). I wish you would have waited for me to get back to you before escalating so quickly and explained your plan to dispute the Paypal payments you made (which immediately froze the funds in my account) so we could have worked something out and I had assurance he would be returned to me. By the time I saw it, the money was deducted from my account and you still had him in hand.
My website terms state clearly that although I do guarantee the health of a shipped gecko, I do not guarantee color. It states: "I do my best to accurately depict a gecko's coloring in the pictures on my website. Since temperature, stress, and other factors can affect color and intensity of color, I cannot guarantee color". Once the gecko leaves here, I have no idea how he/she is set up at a customer's home or if they are stressed.
Not guaranteeing color is standard practice for many crested gecko breeders that ship and also stated in their terms.
I understand Elvis is your first crested gecko and did not meet your expectations and that you are unhappy. I am not a scam artist, horrible person, cheat, liar or con artist or any of the other names you are calling me. I have a positive reputation as a gecko breeder because I am a good person that produces quality, healthy, high-end reptiles. I needed some time to figure out how to make things right with you. I already offered you a pair of geckos worth $610 along with free shipping ($55) to try to make things right several days ago. You didn't want them.
Now you are threatening me. I have been very understanding with you regarding the 5 months it took for you to pay for Elvis due to your multiple personal problems (instead of the 2 months we initially agreed upon). I was always kind and generous with you, even though I was frustrated the sale was taking so long and I wasn't sure if you were a trustworthy person. I never insulted or questioned your integrity like you are doing to me now. I never threatened you (i.e. your e-mail stating: "You picked the wrong person to scam. I might be new to crested geckos enough to fall for your lies, but I am not new to making websites and getting them ranked by meta tags.") I understand that you are unhappy but threatening to ruin my reputation like you are now, along with all your flakiness prior to the purchase, doesn't exactly make me feel good about dealing with you and it makes me not trust you. I have had personal issues going on myself this weekend and apologize for not replying to you same day. I wanted to sit down and figure something out that would make you happy when my head was clear.
I have been breeding cresteds with a stellar reputation for over 14 years. Ship Elvis back to me, and if and when he arrives alive, I will refund you $805 (his full price including shipping). He is not worth $60 as you state someone told you he was on the internet so I am not okay with accepting that and you keeping him. He is a valuable animal to me that I care about and I would like to have him back.
I recommend using
www.shipyourreptiles.com to ship him and you can reuse the box and styrofoam I packed him in. You will need to get a 40 hour heat pack for shipping. This website sells them and tells you in detail how to pack and ship him. They have all the instructions there on how to do it safely and properly and you can even insure him in case the delivery goes wrong somehow. Temperatures need to be above 40 degrees on both of our ends throughout the trip and he needs to be overnighted for arrival by 10:30 am at my house through FedEx or UPS. We also need to work out a day that I am home and he cannot be shipped on a Friday (he could get stuck over the weekend). You can not send him through regular mail and the package must be overnighted for a.m. arrival.
Let me know when you want to do this. I can send you money to cover the shipping up front ($55 which will be deducted from the $805 refund)."
Thank you,
Kati