I'm not sure why everyone is jumping on the "Mike, refund the guys money!" bandwagon. He might have been the seller, but it isn't, nor has it ever been, a "the customer is always right" world.
I know that if I were selling a reptile and conditions weren't right, the guy kept refusing shipment, it wasn't guaranteed someone was going to be there, then I wouldn't ship. I don't care how much the person griped. They can either take acceptable shipping conditions or take their money back.
As others have said...and in a circumstance like this, I'll beat a dead horse...IT'S BEEN 10 YEARS! I'm not siding with either one of them. Both of them could be lying, but it's he said/she said....my third cousins ex girlfriends baby sitters nephews next door neighbor told me...
We'll never know the real truth...as most of us know, there's always a third side to every story...the truth.
I say get on with your lives. It's $17.50 a year...if this were a "Hey, he scammed me out of $5,000"...then I say hammer him, even 10 years later. But, alas...it's not.
It's a waste to post a "bad guy thread", with such shoddy evidence of said scam.
Mike, just because someone says you're a liar doesn't make it so. If it's true, shame on you. If it's not, don't get your panties in a bunch and get over it...you know if it's true or not.
Charles, next time don't wait 10 years. As Christine has said, the BOI has been active since like 2002.