I've not done business with Ed, but I can assure you that I won't.
While I've never believed in the price gouging of US species due what the Asian markets will bare, I've never made any comments about how I felt about it, until he contacted me (unsolicited) to offer me 1.3 peltifer for $700.
I politely declined, here was my reply:
"Hi Ed,
I got a group of 5.5 from you a while back (through Arnie Larson), and they came in with a ton of shell rot, one had a broken tail, etc. Only three of them survived more than a week. I'll pass, particularly at that price. I typically get them anywhere between $50 - $100 a piece.
I've found wild caught peltifer at that size, particularly the stress of capture when gravid, etc. tend to not acclimate well.
Thanks for the offer, though.
My best,
Mike"
Ed then emailed me back, and here is the conversation that ensued:
rom: salmondu @ FaunaClassifieds <
[email protected]> via ayk.herpnet.com
to:
[email protected]
date: Sat, May 11, 2013 at 10:31 AM
subject: Shell rot?
mailed-by: ayk.herpnet.com
Arni did'nt get them from me as I have not sold arni for about 3 years. And you'd be the first to complain. As far as price goes Marc Cantos buys them at $150.00 each last season and Hong Kong is buying at $135.00 each this year almost my entire quota. Sorry you had bad luck with them. Thanks for the feedback. Ed"
from: Mike Myers <
[email protected]>
to: "salmondu @ FaunaClassifieds" <
[email protected]>
date: Sat, May 11, 2013 at 2:37 PM
subject: Re: Shell rot?
mailed-by: gmail.com
Well, with all due respect, Ed... Marc Cantos isn't exactly a benchmark for accurate market pricing, considering everything he sells is near double average market prices.
As for what Hong Kong is paying.... I live in the US. I can pay $200 for a plane ticket, fly down to my friend's place in Alabama, stay for a week, and collect my two a day for personal use quota, and boost my collection for the cost of shipping. So for you to offer me $175 a piece when overseas is buying at $135 seems a little backwards, don't you think?
I'm a collector, not a breeder. I keep small groups for enjoyment, and surplus my offspring. I actually enjoy getting harder to find species in the hands of people who might not otherwise be able to get them, or collecting wild specimens for the purpose of captive propagation to lessen the need to collect hundreds from the wild... not just try and get the highest price out of what's living in my back yard (and yes, I understand they may not be literally in your back yard).
My best,
Mike
from: Ed Jones <
[email protected]>
to: Mike Myers <
[email protected]>
date: Sat, May 11, 2013 at 3:14 PM
subject: Re: Shell rot?
mailed-by: comcast.net
signed-by: comcast.net
I don't think so Mike.
But you keep dreamin. And I don't think you can fly down to Bama (RT) for $200.00. Furthermore Bama stopped all collecting of all Turtles. Otherwise Mike Guglicrook would be doing it.
Now if you want to negotiate a deal of some kind I would work with you. Also I've know Marc since he moved to Fl. and worked for Mike Ellard (All these efing Mikes) Sorry!
Anyway do you want to work with me? I'm negotiable on everything except "PREPAY". On that its my way or the highway.
Best regards,
Ed
Edward C. Jones
(678) 402-8820
from: Mike Myers <
[email protected]>
to: Ed Jones <
[email protected]>
date: Sat, May 11, 2013 at 3:40 PM
subject: Re: Shell rot?
mailed-by: gmail.com
I'd read Alabama Administrative code again, Ed.
Alabama Administrative Code 220-2-142, section 2C, clearly states:
Nothing in this regulation prohibits the taking for personal use of up to two legal turtles per day by hand, dip
net or hook and line however, no person shall take more than two day from the wild in this state, to include public waters.
Published 3/13/13.
And guess what's NOT listed in 220-2-92?? Here's a list for you:
Malaclemys terrapin pileata
Gopherus polyphemus
Graptemys pulchra
Pseudemys alabamensis
Macroclemys temminckii
Graptemys barbouri
Graptemys nigrinoda
Graptemys ernsti
So maybe instead of trying to be a smart ass, if you want to ask someone to do business with you, know what you're talking about.
But I thought I was pretty clear that I wasn't interested.
from: Ed Jones <
[email protected]>
to: Mike Myers <
[email protected]>
date: Sat, May 11, 2013 at 3:46 PM
subject: Re: Shell rot?
mailed-by: comcast.net
signed-by: comcast.net
Oh, I'm sorry ASSHOLE!
---------------------------
Now, in the meantime, Ed had also responded to me on Fauna, saying the following:
Mike,
I just got off phone with Arni. He says your mistaken. You may get baby's for $50 to $100 each but not full on breeder adults. I got an order 2 weeks ago from a guy in Calif. for 100 adult 50.50 @ $125.00 each full on adults. BTW pelts don't do well in water that is higher than 70F degrees. Unless your planning on eating them. Thanks. Ed
I wrote him back to see what part I was mistaken about (the price, or where they came from), but I haven't since heard back from him. If I was wrong, I'd gladly discuss it. But the group I got in August of 2012, via Arnie Larson, was said to a shipment from Ed (I still have the texts saying so).
In any event, based on the replies I've seen, and the reaction I got simply from proving him wrong, I wouldn't trust him to do right if a deal went wrong.