Wow, this thread seems a bit premature. I honestly can't see anything wrong with the geckos in those tiny pictures, and I looked hard. But then again, I am not a gecko expert; I mostly keep snakes. I do, however, think that the seller was being more than accommodating to the OP, but the OP was just angry and wanted to attack.
Jeff, I can understand being angry and upset when new animals arrive and they are not exactly as you expected. However, you can get a LOT more flies with honey than with vinegar, as the old saying goes. I'm not trying to bash you; I'm not taking sides here at all, as I am not a gecko expert. However, I do think this could have been handled far less painfully for you both.
Case in point- I once bought a beautiful pair of Savu pythons at a reptile show and got the seller's information. The day after I brought them home, I noticed that the female seemed a bit wheezy. I contacted the seller and calmly asked if she'd ever had issues while in his care. We discussed how he had been keeping them, the sizes of their rack bins, temps and humidity in his house, etc as well as my quarantine room conditions, and he said if I needed to get her vet care he would refund me. I told him that I would keep an eye on her for a few days and let him know if anything changed or if I had to take her to a vet. I bumped her temps up a few degrees, and sat tight. She clouded up for shed, shed out 5 days later and was perfect. My thoughts are that the dry skin from the upcoming shed blocked her nostrils a bit. The seller was polite and helpful; I was polite to the seller despite my concerns, and it worked out in the end. The animal turned out fine and I ended up cultivating a friendship with this breeder. I could very easily have called him and screamed "YOU SOLD ME A SICK SNAKE. YOU DON"T KNOW WHAT YOU ARE DOING!!" Had I done that, I am sure I would have been told to take a hike.
In the future Jeff, I hope that you can learn to be patient and bear with a seller. All Peter wanted was proof of your claim to assure himself that you weren't going to screw him over, while you felt HE had screwed YOU over. Politeness on your part could have gone a long long way towards getting you a result you were happy with.
And Peter, I understand your frustration with Jeff's poor grammar. Bad grammar and misspellings are a pet peeve of mine as well. However, not everyone has gone to great schools, and some people are just not able to catch on to grammar. I am working on a Ph.D, and I know people in my program who are absolutely brilliant at their work, but need anything they write edited and checked by at least two other people. I think that your attacking Jeff's grammar was a bit low. He's not nearly as bad as some I've seen on here.
Anyway, that's just my $0.02.